But wait, you say, TV is doing fine. There are a zillion cable channels and streaming is a big thing and getting bigger. And you would be correct to say so. But the title is a bit of a cheat. By "TV" I first mean traditional "over the air" broadcast TV. But I think that cable TV's days are also numbered. It will just take a little longer. And if broadcast TV no longer exists and cable TV no longer exists I contend that "TV" is dead. Whatever is still around would be something else. So, as is my wont, let's dive into a little history. The first public demonstration of a complete TV system (cameras, TV sets, control rooms, etc.) took place at the 1939 New York World's Fair. That makes TV 75 years old. I confidently predict that it will be dead before it turns 100. I actually expect broadcast TV to be gone within about 10 years and cable TV to disappear less than 10 years later. How and why?
TV, like a great many things, is a prisoner of its technology. In 1939 the technology of the day was barely capable of doing TV. The equipment was complex, expensive, finicky, and inflexible. Pictures were captured at a few locations on the fairgrounds and delivered to TV sets located at a few other locations on the fairgrounds. But it got a lot of publicity, it was successful as a proof of concept, and it provided a foundation on which improvements could be built.
Then things pretty much stopped because of the outbreak of World War II. That is, work stopped on TV itself. But considerable progress was made in improving the technological foundations of TV. So when the war ended people were very excited about the future of TV. And some of what had been hard in 1939 was now much easier and some of what had been impossible in 1939 was now possible. So what was possible?
TV cameras and studios were possible. TV sets were possible. But it was all pretty expensive. And there was the "chicken or egg" problem. To sell TV sets you need TV shows. But to justify the cost of building TV studios and doing production you need an audience who would view the commercials that would pay for all of it. But people took the leap of faith and built the studios praying that once they were on the air people would buy sets. And they did.
But cameras were expensive and finicky. They also needed a lot of power and light to work. So they were only practical in a studio situation. And the only way to get the shows to the viewers was to broadcast it over the air like radio stations were doing. So that's what people did. And in the beginning it was nearly impossible and also very expensive to send a signal more than about 50 miles. The solution, was also one taken from radio. Special cables were built to connect one city to another. They had to have extremely high performance for the time so they were very expensive to build and maintain. So at first only a few cities in the northeast were hooked together. Then the cable was extended down the east coast. Then it was further extended across to the west coast, but initially only to California. Over the decades the system of TV cables for shipping signals from city to city was extended to more and more of the country until finally, pretty much every city of any size was "on the cable".
So these early TV stations were pretty isolated. That meant that there were few or no opportunities to get a live feed from elsewhere in the country. So these stations did a lot of local production. At one time pretty much every TV station in the country had their own local host for a children's show that they ran in the "after school" slot in the early evening. And pretty soon someone figured how to hook a movie projector to a TV camera. This made it easy for TV stations to broadcast old movies. Hollywood had lots of old movies around that they would rent cheaply to the TV stations. So soon pretty much every TV station ran movies at various times of the day.
Then someone said "hey, let's hook up a movie camera to a TV set". That made it easy but fairly expensive to get TV shows from "on the cable" TV stations to "off the cable" TV stations. The TV stations in Seattle, the area I live in was an "off the cable" station for a long time. Much of the surviving material from the early era of TV comes from Seattle. East coast shows would be put on the cable to San Francisco. The San Francisco station would "Kinescope" (the name of the TV to film process) the show and put the film on a plane to Seattle. After a delay of less than a day (light speed in those days) the show could be aired in Seattle. Once the show aired no one wanted the film any more. So a lot of it ended up in the garages of station employees where it was discovered years later. Why use this clunky method? Because at that time Kinescopes worked better than anything else.
Seattle, had a different problem that turned out to be important to the evolution of TV, lots of geography. Seattle is a hilly town. And for technical reasons broadcast TV signals go in a straight line and do not go through hills. So one of the local stations came up with an idea. Why not put an antenna on the top of the hill and run feeds to all the houses on the shadow side of the hill? It was called Community Antenna TV or CATV for short. This morphed into cable TV and grew to the behemoth that the cable industry is now.
Anyhow, Seattle eventually got hooked on to the cable (old style usage) and the CATV idea pioneered in Seattle spread to the rest of the country and blossomed into cable TV, or cable (new style) for short. We'll get back to cable in a minute. But first, some questions.
Why use kinescopes, the film based technology, as a recording technology? The answer, of course, is that originally that was the only functional technology. Kinescopes were replaced by video tape when videotape technology became available. Similarly, why was TV originally black and white? The answer here is similar. Technology initially could not do color. Color TV sets had to be developed. Color TV cameras had to be developed. Then color studio technology and broadcast technology and cable (old style usage of the word) had to be developed. CBS was the first group to develop a usable color system. But the broadcast signal was not compatible with black and white. TV stations would have had to broadcast two different signals on two different channels, one for the black and white system and one for the color one. Although complex, this might have happened. But before a decision could be made RCA, then a giant electronics company that happened to own NBC, developed a "compatible" system. One signal would be broadcast. Black and white sets would effectively not see the color components so they would do their black and white thing without needing any modification. Color sets would know how to process the additional information to put a color picture on their screens. It took a lot of technological advance to allow the market share of color to overtake that of black and white. But the technology advanced, costs declined, and after a while, black and white sets disappeared completely.
The changes from kinescopes to video tape and from black and white to color were evolutionary. They required technology to advance and for money to be found to develop and deploy the new technology. They also required manufacturing methods to advance so that the cost of the new more complex equipment could be brought down to the point where people figured the additional cost of color was a good deal. All this happened so TV moved on smoothly.
And there was another area where things moved on smoothly as new technology replaced old technology and that's on the CATV/cable front. (We're back!) CATV started out as an effort of one TV station in Seattle to get their signal to the back side of some hills. When the original CATV system was built there was only one TV station. But soon there were several. The CATV technology was upgraded to handle multiple channels. Then it was upgraded some more to pull in stations that were further away but still in the general area, stations that could be pulled in using sophisticated antennas and the like. But it was still impractical to pull in stations that were far away. A cable (old style) could be built but it was just too expensive to pay for itself. But the technology rapidly improved in terms of the number of channels that could be handled. There just weren't enough channels to fill all the slots.
And there was another problem. People quickly noticed that the picture on their TV was a lot better when their TV was hooked up to the CATV system than it was when they used their own antenna. And many people used inexpensive antennas nick named rabbit ears. The good news was that the rabbit ears were easy manipulated when you needed to change their orientation, something you often had to do when switching from one station to another as each station's transmission antenna was in a different direction. The bad news was that rabbit ears seemed to require constant fiddling even if you weren't changing the channel. None of this fiddling was necessary if you were getting your signals from the CATV system. So people who technically didn't need to hook up to the CATV system did so anyhow. The fees were low so it was a cheap price to pay to avoid all the fiddling. So, in spite of the fact that they only gave you access to a few channels, CATV systems became quite popular.
And these two facts, the fact that CATV systems were popular and the fact that CATV systems often had extra unused channel slots was noticed by Ted Turner. Along with everything else there was another technological advance. Since things were working pretty well people were putting up lots of TV stations. The original 12 channel setup called VHF (which actually enabled only about 6 channels in a particular market for technical reasons) was extended to include something called UHF, which added about 60 additional channels (30 or more useful channels). People were lazy so they mostly stuck with the original VHF channels and, for technical reasons the UHF channels didn't work as well, but a UHF channel could be run profitably if you were careful. And Turner owned channel 17 in Atlanta. Turner changed the call letters to WTCG (for Turner Communications Group) and later to WTBS (for Turner Broadcasting System). It was initially a modest business making a modest profit.
Remember kinescopes. They were replaced by video tape systems. Remember the cable systems that were used to send signals between cities. They worked pretty well but they were very expensive to build and to maintain. Then along came communications satellites. Satellites are very expensive. But with relatively small and relatively inexpensive antennas two TV stations could share programming by relaying it through the satellite. Soon it became less expensive to do this than to use the cable. And then it became a lot less expensive. Turner was the first to notice this and marry it up with the two CATV facts that Turner had noticed.
Turner leased a satellite channel and purchased a satellite antenna for channel 17. Then he offered to give his WTBS signal away to CATV systems. (He made his money on the advertising.) All they had to do was buy the downlink satellite antenna. And he helped them with that too. (The more CATV systems that signed up the higher advertising rate he could charge.) The combination was wildly successful. WTBS soon started calling itself a superstation and other superstations quickly followed. It didn't matter that the WTBS feed was not that different from the feed of local stations that were already on the CATV system. It was a novelty. Then Turner got broadcast rights to all the Atlanta Braves baseball games. It didn't matter that the Braves were not very good. There were lots of CATV systems in markets that had no major league baseball team. We now know how popular broadcast sports are but it was a surprise when Turner pioneered it with the Braves. There were a lot of legal problems to be worked out to make superstations successful. But Turner worked them all out. And he proved that all the technological problems could also be solved.
WTBS started out as just another local UHF TV station. But Turner turned it into the first superstation. He then pioneered CNN, a 24 hour news channel, another idea no one else had thought of. Here too others quickly got in the game and found other formulas. We how have ESPN for Sports, various shopping channels, various religion channels, various channels that provide their own TV shows, etc. In this latter category HBO pioneered the idea of high end shows for a "small" extra fee. But we also now have any number of channels like A&E or USA that provide fodder that is indistinguishable from TV shows found on the old line networks. A typical cable package now includes hundreds of offerings catering to pretty much any taste out there. And CATV is now just "cable" and "cable" is so ubiquitous that most people are unaware of the old usage of "cable" to refer to the method networks like ABC, NBC, and CBS used to deliver their shows to their local "affiliate" stations around the country.
And a lot of this evolution of CATV to cable was enabled by technological improvements. And a lot of this was evolutionary rather than revolutionary. Using satellites instead of the city to city cable system was a matter of changing the technology while leaving the functionality alone. And CATV systems went from one channel to several channels to a couple of dozen channels to about a hundred channels to about a thousand channels as they evolved into cable systems. But the change was solely in the number of channels that could practically be accommodated. The functionality was left unchanged.
And before I leave this subject let me ask a question. Do you like your cable system? For upwards of 90% of cable customers the answer is "NO". Cable companies have added features over the years, principally more channels. But the fees they charge have gone up too. Most customers believe the "value proposition", how valuable the service is as compared to the cost, has deteriorated. In the old days people would happily sign up with a CATV system to get essentially what was available to them for free because the small fee the CATV system charged seemed like a good deal. You got less hassle (no more fiddling with the rabbit ears) and a better picture. Now the cable fees seem sky high, you are roped into getting a bunch of channels you don't want in order to get the few you do want, and customer service sucks. Does this sound like an opportunity?
And, while all this technological evolution has been going on in the TV business there are whole other industries that use the same technology base as TV but have heretofore had no connection to the TV business. The key industry for the purposes of our discussion is the computer business. The computer business bumped along for years with only the most marginal connection to TV. The studios that make the TV shows figured out early that they could sex up their shows by putting a bunch of computers in them. That was pretty much as much of a connection as there was for a long time. Then the computer business started churning out small inexpensive machines that used a GUI, a Graphical User Interface. The display used as a computer screen is a CRT, essentially a souped up TV set. And at some point it became apparent that the process used to generate the "Graphical" on a computer could be used to produce images for purely entertainment purposes. And this observation is the foundation of the now massive computer games industry. Computers became adept at creating and manipulating images and, for that matter, sound. So computers could be used in the production stages of making TV shows. Interesting but not revolutionary.
But the computer industry also spent decades getting better and better at hooking computers together in networks. The original "long haul" computer networks (akin to the old city to city cable system used behind the scenes by TV networks) were pathetically slow. But they kept getting faster. And over decades the technology for linking literally billions of computers together, what we now know as the Internet, was developed and implemented. And then there was a technological breakthrough. Long haul fiber optic cables were developed. These cables had vastly more capacity than the old long haul computer network equipment. They were also simpler and cheaper to operate. Soon they had more capacity than the city to city cable system TV was using. They even had more capacity than satellite TV links. It was now possible to send vast amounts of data from one computer to another anywhere in the world. Sending a live TV signal from one place to the other went from being expensive and requiring a bunch of specialized equipment and expertise to being no big deal.
In the early days TV sets were manufactured in far greater numbers than computer displays so most CRTs were manufactured to meet TV specifications not computer specifications. But in the '80s that changed. And the computer CRTs were better. You could slot in a computer grade CRT in to replace a TV screen but you couldn't slot a TV grade CRT in to replace a computer screen. So manufacturers started making all computer grade CRTs and using the crappy ones to support the TV market. And the computer grade CRTs kept getting better and better as computer users demanded higher and higher resolution. So the performance gulf between a computer grade CRT and a TV grade one continued to grow. And the market for computer grade CRTs grew at a faster rate than the market for TV grade ones. At some point all TV grade CRT manufacturing shut down.
Then the "flat screen" revolution happened. Technology was developed to create a flat thin computer display. This was a massive improvement over the old CRT, a bulky device that had to extend quite a distance behind the screen. And the inside of this big device had to be kept in a continuous vacuum. So the whole thing had to be strong enough so it wouldn't implode. And that meant it had to be heavy. As soon as flat screens of sufficiently high quality and sufficiently low price became available the CRT market collapsed. And remember, all this flat screen technology, even in the early days, had all the capabilities necessary to be used as a screen for a TV.
In fact, remember the whole "compatible" color discussion above. Compatibility has always been very important in TV. None of the new stuff can obsolete the old stuff to the point where the old stuff stops working. So the quality of the TV experience was frozen at the level attainable in the early '70s. This was definitely not true in the computer business. Ways were found to introduce bigger, better, faster, displays that did not obsolete the old ones to the point that the old ones would stop working. So computers kept getting better and better while, for the most part, TVs stayed the same.
This impasse on the TV side was finally broken by the "high definition TV" war. The Japanese had pretty much taken over the manufacture of CRTS both for TVs and for computers. At some point they became impatient with the fact that TVs were frozen while computer displays were moving ahead. And they saw an opportunity to squeeze the modest amount of non-Japanese CRT manufacturing left completely out of business. So they came up with a new specification for a high definition TV. They said they would roll it out in Japan and work to roll it out in the rest of the world. And at this time there were several competing TV standards. While a computer screen could be sold anywhere in the world because there was only one standard, several different TV models had to be made, each set up to work within the standards of each market. So a single world wide high definition TV standard had a lot going for it from the Japanese perspective.
This initiative scared the bejesus out of the U.S. electronics industry. U.S. manufacturers had once dominated the market the way the Japanese now did. If the Japanese succeeded then it looked like it was over forever for U.S. manufacturers. So they went to work. Some of them noticed that the Japanese standard was essentially a souped up version of the old TV standard. In short hand it was an "analog" standard. But the computer business, still dominated by U.S. players like Microsoft, used what was short handed as "digital" standards. And remember these digital standards had permitted the flexibility necessary for allowing new computer displays to get better while allowing the old ones to keep working. So coming up with a "digital" high definition specification was proposed. The immediate question was "could it be made to work at a reasonable price"? With the computer display business as a foundation the answer was "yes". The next question was "could it be made to fit broadly within the current system"? Here there were problems.
Originally the amount of bandwidth necessary to get things to fit seemed excessive. Then someone suggested compression. This is a mathematical technique for shrinking the amount of data it takes to represent an image. There are lots of blobs in a typical TV picture where every "pixel" is the same. Why not send the pixel value along once then add instructions for where to put it. Compression was quickly found to solve the bandwidth problem. It was easily shown that TV pictures could be compressed enough so that the new digital high definition transmission would take up the same amount of bandwidth as the old analog TV channels. This meant that some old "analog" channels could be flipped into new "digital" channels without having to change anything else. Then it came down to cost and feasibility. Could this new much more complex equipment be built and could it be built for a reasonable price. As we now know, the answers to these questions turned out to be "yes". We have completed the transition of broadcast TV from "analog" to "digital" and from "standard definition" to "High definition". But it was done in such a way as to leave the old "TV" system pretty much in place.
And that's the end of the history lesson. To recapitulate, we have a "TV" system that looks pretty much like it has for many decades. Oh, we now have lots more channels and we have high definition but it is pretty much the same system. This is ridiculous. We could do a much better job of it. But we are locked into the current system. Or are we? Powerful forces like things as they are. The networks like it. The local TV stations like it. The cable companies like it. And it turns out a lot of cable channels like ESPN like it. But there are some cracks starting to appear in the system. The most obvious is You Tube. You can download vast quantities of video from You Tube. And, from a technical point of view, You Tube videos are the equal of anything you can get on TV. So You Tube could completely replace TV if all we have to worry about are technical issues. More original content is uploaded to You Tube in a day than any single person could watch in a lifetime. But most of it is crap. So, while You Tube shows that there is another way, in its current form it does not represent a threat to the "TV" system. The "TV" system consistently delivers higher quality content. So, by itself, You Tube is not enough to do TV in. Fortunately, there is more out there than just You Tube.
Remember HBO? Their business model is "deliver premium content at an affordable price premium". The most obvious company to follow this model but in a non-TV way is Netflix. They are using the same business model. They just replace the "TV" delivery system with the "Internet download" delivery system. In the same way that HBO made a splash with shows like "Sex and the City" and "The Sopranos", Netflix has made a splash with "House of Cards" and "Orange is the New Black". They have been successful enough with this model to attract competition. Amazon is trying to do the same thing with there "Prime" service. They have rolled out "Alpha House" and other shows. And guess who is also joining the "streaming" set? HBO! HBO has announced that they are going to make all their content (current and historical) available as a web based streaming service called "HBO Go".
The success of Netflix shows that an alternative to the current "TV" delivery system can be successful from a business perspective. But can we go "all the way" to completely replacing the "TV" system? If it could be pulled off it would be another "disruptive technology" success. Disruptive technology succeeds by meeting an old need in a new way that is very damaging to the "old way" companies. For this to be possible there must be weaknesses and inadequacies in how the "old way" companies do business. It turned out that there were certainly weaknesses and inadequacies in the music business. Is the same true for the "TV" business? Well let's take a high level look at the pieces.
TV shows are made by studios, networks and other content providers. The digital revolution has already swept over the production operations of these organizations and left them largely unchanged. The tricks and tools are cooler but the process is pretty much the same. The process at its best is driven by creative people and there is no technological replacement for creative people. Content providers want to be paid for their work but they pretty much don't care who pays as long as the check is big enough. They are just as happy to cash a Netflix check as they are to cash an NBC check. And that's a problem for the down stream players.
The next step is the aggregators, the people who purchase the shows, collect them together, and send them along. Currently these are people like the aforementioned NBC and its old line network brethren like ABC. But they are also, intermediate aged players like A&E or USA. And the list extends right down to the newest cable channel on the block. These aggregators then do deals with the cable companies like Comcast. Then (if you have bought the right cable package) the show is available to you the viewer on your TV set. But in some cases there is another level that still exists but we have largely forgotten about, the local "broadcast" TV stations. Fare provided by the old line networks like NBC doesn't go straight to Comcast. Instead the local station pretends to broadcast it and Comcast pretends to pick it up "off the air" and send it along to your home over its local cable system.
Most people have forgotten but local TV stations still actually broadcast their signal. You can buy the digital equivalent of the old rabbit ear antenna for about $50 and pick their signal up for free, at least theoretically. In principal you can sever your connection to the likes of Comcast (or whoever your local cable provider is). And, other than the $50 up front cost, it's free. But just as in the old CATV days it is sometimes hard to pick up a good signal and you are limited to the local TV stations that are nearby and not on the other side of a hill or other obstruction. And this is a problem for the old line "TV" system. If local TV stations stopped broadcasting they would save a lot of money. Transmitters soak up a lot of electricity and keeping a TV tower in good repair is not cheap either. And, as long as they maintained their connection to the cable company, most people would not notice if they stopped broadcasting because very few people actually view local station content by picking it out of the air. So why not just stop broadcasting?
Because, due to the traditional "broadcast" nature of their business a local station is granted an exclusive license on network content for their broadcast area. What this means in practical terms is that the cable company pays a fee, a rather hefty fee, for the right to use the signal of the local TV station. And there is a federal "must carry" law that requires cable operators to make a deal with all the local broadcast TV stations. This rather tenuous legal foundation for all this nonsense is what guarantees a large chunk of the local station's revenue. And that revenue stream can easily be the difference between a profitable operation and one that runs at a loss. So for local stations it is imperative that the current system remain in place. It would be easier and cheaper for Comcast to pick the NBC feed off the satellite just like they do with A&E but current law requires them to jump through these unnecessary hoops that benefit the local stations. Nobody cares that we the viewer don't see any benefit.
And remember how the local stations used to provide a lot of local content. Well, since then most of that local content has disappeared. There are no local kids shows. And if you want to see old movies you'll have to go to one of the cable channels that specialize in that sort of thing. Most of what they broadcast today is network content or syndicated shows provided by one or another of the usual cast of content providers. There are two areas where local stations are still very active. That is news and sports. College and professional teams used to do deals with local stations to carry non-network games. And most games fell into this category. But now pretty much every pro game is broadcast by one network or another. So if the game shows up on a local station's broadcast then it's because the station has the rights through one network affiliation or another. And the same thing is rapidly overtaking college sports. The big football conferences are all forming "sports channels" that specialize in the games of the schools that are members of the conference. The era when a local TV station could do a stand alone deal with a local college to broadcast some or all of its games is rapidly coming to a close.
That leaves news. Local stations broadcast a lot of news. But much of it is repetitive. It is common to have a 90 minute block of local news in the evening. But this mostly consists of the same thirty minutes of content repeated three times to accommodate the varied schedules of viewers. And regional "all news channels" are emerging. There is one in my area that covers my state (Washington) and a couple of adjacent states. There is a lot of repetition here but they seem to have plenty of time to cover all the news for the entire region at least as thoroughly and often more thoroughly that the local stations do. This is already a cable channel. It is not broadcast over the air. I see these kinds of operations as a viable replacement for the news operations of local stations.
So local stations seem completely unnecessary. But cable operators are safe, right? Well, you remember how everybody hates their cable operator? And remember the part about cable operators having to compensate local broadcast channels. Well, this whole "compensate" thing is true up and down the cable lineup. It is most obvious with premium channels like HBO. But, with the exception of the religion channels and the shopping channels the cable companies pay for everything. That's why bundling is so important to them. Do you like sports? How about hunting and fishing stuff, or science stuff, or history stuff, or geography stuff, or nature stuff, or reality shows, or game shows? Somewhere in that list is at least one thing you don't like and probably several things you would just as soon do without. But you are subsidizing it, all of it. Cable operators bundle things together so that you will be forced to get a lot of things you don't like or don't care about in order to get a few things you like. You end up subsidizing everything in the bundle whether you like it or not.
You don't pay a lot to subsidize any one channel. But you subsidize a lot of channels and it adds up. And, since the cable companies get money for carrying them, pretty much everyone gets the religion channels and the shopping channels, even though most viewers would rather do without one or both of those categories. I doubt a typical viewer watches content from even 10% of the channels offered. They would much rather get a much smaller list of channels consisting of only the ones they are actually interested in. But they are not given this "a la carte" option. Neither the cable companies nor the studios want to take the chance that "a la carte" will translate to "less money for me". So here you have a situation where the general public wants a la carte by a vast margin but the cable industry for their own reasons does not want to offer it to them. So, if Internet streaming could offer viewers an a la carte experience especially if it turned out to be cheaper than the current cable model then, assuming it worked well, people would flock to it.
And, as I said, we are moving toward it. We are seeing high quality original content being offered by Netflix, Amazon, HBO (soon) and others. That's the good news. But it is not currently possible to duplicate the cable experience with Internet streaming. You can 't get old line network content (NBC, etc.) first run on the web because web access to this content has been blocked so far. A company called Aereo thought they had figured out pull this off. Technologically, it's a piece of cake. The problems are legal. They lost their case in the U.S. Supreme Court recently and just filed for bankruptcy. It may be possible to get around the legal obstacles that brought Aereo down but no one has figured out how yet.
I think I have convinced you that there are no technical problems left stopping the creation of an alternative to the current "TV" system. So the problems lie elsewhere. And you may have already figured out one of the big ones. I have listed Netflix, Amazon, and HBO as content sources. I haven't talked about others like Hulu that offer access to TV content from the old line networks. But it is available on delay and not everything is available. (And CBS does not make its shows available to Hulu. You have to go somewhere else to find them.) Hulu is only the most well known site providing streaming access to "TV" content. There are others. And that's a problem. For all that we dislike cable companies, they are a "one stop shopping" provider.
I can get my local stations, my cable stations (like A&E, USA, etc.) my "free" sports channels like ESPN, my premium channels like HBO, and on and on and on, all from the same cable company. I may have to pay a lot of money to get them all. But once I hand a chunk of change over to the cable company once a month I am all set. To try to do this on the web I have to pay a fee to Hulu (to get premium content). I then have to pay another fee to Nerflix, and another fee to Amazon, and another fee to HBOGo, etc. Its a lot of money. It's also the opposite of "one stop shopping". Trying to put together a cable-like package right now may end up costing more than cable. And I can't just change the channel. I have to switch from this application (or web site) to that application to the other web site. That's the opposite of what made the original CATV experience so popular. So we're not there yet.
But I think we will eventually get there. The first thing I expect to go is the "broadcast" operations of local TV stations. The FCC is about to auction a big chunk of radio spectrum. Everybody expects it to go for fantastic amounts of money. The spectrum will go to open up things up for smart phones and other mobile devices. And people definitely want to be able to "watch TV" on their smart phone or tablet while they are out and about. If we shut down the broadcast part of local TV stations then this will free up another big chunk of radio spectrum. No one thinks we are at the end of the growth curve for mobile devices so someone will be willing to pay fantastic amounts of additional money for this additional spectrum if and when it becomes available. Frankly, the only thing that is keeping the local stations broadcasting is their concern that this would fatally weaken their negotiating position with the cable companies. Maybe they can be bought off with a big limp sum payment.
But I think that local TV stations are already in trouble even if they can keep things as they now are. I think the business climate has turned against them. Advertisers have plenty of options and I think it is harder and harder for the local stations to deliver eyeballs efficiently. If networks could dump them and deal directly with the cable companies it would save them a lot of money and hassle so they would be willing to throw their local "partners" overboard if they thought it would help their bottom line enough. So on one side you have local TV stations. They are heavily wired into the political system at the local and state level but depend on their network partners to handle things at the national level. If that support at the national level dries up they are in big trouble. And the critical decisions in all this are made at the national level. On the other side you have the cable companies. Getting rid of the local stations eliminates a bunch of headaches and, assuming they can get a better deal directly from the networks, it saves them money. And the mobile types really want the spectrum. They are not currently making a push because they are busy dickering for the spectrum now coming on the market, spectrum that was freed up by the transition for analog to digital TV. They also believe that if they got in a fight they would lose. It is bad idea to make powerful people mad at you and then not get what you are fighting for. But they will have digested the new spectrum within a couple of years. And if the political position of the local stations continues to weaken they may decide they can win the fight. At that point it will be "go in with all guns blazing".
So I see local TV stations first losing the over the air part of their business then just losing. And local TV stations are a key component of the "TV" system. The other, and currently bigger component, is the cable operators. They are still very powerful because they are very profitable and they have leveraged their money and the favors they can do for politicians. Remember, Comcast, for instance, owns both NBC and MSNBC. They can be very nasty or very nice to politicians who are out of favor or in favor. I think they are mostly not that blatant. Instead they have a giant lobbying operation and contribute generously to political campaigns. But there is no doubt that they are heavyweight players in D.C.
They will fiercely defend their turf. But ultimately they can be done in in the same way the music industry was done in. There is a large pool of potential customers who are dying to get out from under their thumbs. And there is lots of money that could be stripped out of their operation. A "lean mean" Internet operation has lots of ways to undercut them on price and beat them on service, all at the same time. No one has figured it out yet. The Hulu people tried to be the single source for all things television, as long as it was second run. They were done in by squabbling among the executives that run the various companies involved. This opened the door to people like Netflix and Amazon. But none of these new players look like they have cracked the riddle of how to provide a cable-like "one stop shopping" experience. But this is not a technology problem. It's a political problem. Theoretically, it is also a legal problem. But, with the right politics, the law can be changed. I believe this problem too will be solved. And I think it will be solved in less than 25 years.
Sunday, November 23, 2014
Wednesday, November 12, 2014
The Republican party is Anti-American
I'm sure your first response to the title is "but they just won big in the midterm elections". But those same midterm elections featured campaign spending of roughly $4 billion and featured a turnout of less than half of the eligible citizenry. And, although the ratings of the very institutions the politicians were running for jobs in have popularity ratings of under 10%, more than 90% of incumbents were re-elected. I don't think you can draw any conclusions from the Republican victory.
There is also a strong case for my thesis based on GOP domestic policies. But, in order to constrain the discussion to a manageable scope, I am going to restrict myself to foreign affairs. And my starting point is an article by Richard Haass in the November/December issue of Foreign Affairs. In "The Unraveling", Mr. Haass takes a broad look at U.S. foreign policy and prescribes what he thinks should be done. For those of you not familiar with him, Mr. Haass is a long time figure in foreign policy circles. He is currently president of The Council on Foreign Relations. Before that he held positions in both the George H. W. Bush administration and that of his son. He is neither a right wing bomb thrower nor a left wing ideolog. He is a right leaning member of the establishment and, therefore, no friend of President Obama. In fact, he would characterize his piece as a critique of Obama's foreign policy. So let's see what he says and how this lines up with the pronouncements and actions of Republican politicians.
Mr. Haass sees the fundamental foreign policy issue as "a perennial tension in the world between the forces of order and the forces of disorder". Not surprisingly, he is in favor of order. He titles one section of his piece "The post-Cold War order is unraveling, and while not perfect, will be missed." He goes on to say "[t]hese days, the balance between order and disorder is shifting toward the latter. Some of the reasons are structural, but some are the result of bad choices made by important players -- and at least some of those can and should be corrected." My thesis in a nutshell is that Republicans are actively supporting these bad choices. So let's take a tour of the places Mr. Haass discusses and what he says should be done. Then let's see what Republicans are saying and doing.
He starts with the middle east. "In the Middle East, for example, order has been undermined by a tradition of top heavy, often corrupt, and illegitimate governments". He then lists their sins. So what's the U.S. contribution? "With more than a decade of hindsight, the decision to oust Saddam and remake Iraq looks even more mistaken than it did at the time." These actions were undertaken by a Republican administration with strong support up and down the party. And President Obama opposed it. So Obamas is on the right side of the argument and Republicans are on the wrong side. And remember, it is Haass who is providing the definition of what is right and what is wrong.
He then chastises the President for supporting the ousters in Libya and Egypt. Yet the governments of both countries fit Haass' definition of governments that have made things worse. So what, according to Haass, was the U.S. supposed to do? Were we to continue to support the old bad governments that were, according to the Haass definition, wrong governments? Yes! Apparently in both cases we should make an exception. So was their a strong argument for continued support of these old regimes by Republican politicians? No. Senator McCain and others were vigorously arguing for intervention, and earlier, and more of it. Elsewhere, Haass criticizes the U.S. "lack of effective follow-up". But it is at this point, when the Obama Administration was trying to impellent effective follow-up, that Republican support for intervention in these countries turned to opposition. The switch effectively sabotaged any chance for success.
Haass has something to say on Syria. He apparently approves of "support for the ouster of President Bashar al-Assad" but faults Obama for doing "little to bring it about". Here Republicans were loudly supportive of arming and supporting the "moderate opposition". We now know that the largest component of that opposition was what we now call ISIS/ISIL. Neither Haass nor the Republicans have given Obama any credit for pulling off the extremely tricky and difficult task of extracting large stockpiles of chemical weapons from an active war zone. Nor have they provided any useful help in identifying the "moderate" opposition or encouraging the Turks, Saudis, or other "moderate" Arab nations to participate in Syria in active and helpful ways. Instead, their contribution has consisted primarily of "whatever Obama is doing is wrong".
There was a time when the rule that said "politics stops at the water's edge". (The quotation is attributed to Republican Senator Vanderbilt in 1947.) There was a sound reason for this. As Haass says "[t]he world can see this", namely divisiveness around our foreign policy. This encourages the thinking in our opponents that "if we don't like what the current guys are offering we can just wait until the other guys get in and see if we can get a better deal from them". It also undermines the current administration's ability to make promises in order to secure a deal on some contentious issue. But the Republican party no longer feels bound by this rule. The Republicans may well block the implementation of the promise merely to score domestic political points. With this in mind, it is all the more impressive that Obama was able to bring the chemical weapons deal in Syria to a successful conclusion. No one should be in favor of a regime like Assad's having access to any chemical weapons, let alone the large stockpiles Assad had. Returning to Haass' piece, . . .
Haass makes note of and apparently approves of Obama's tilt toward Asia. His criticism here is "one of omission", that Obama hasn't sufficiently tilted. Have Republicans made a coherent argument, or for that matter any argument at all, that the tilt is a bad idea? No. But they have, as part of their general policy of "whatever Obama's for, we're against" policy, thrown roadblocks in the way where they could. They have tried to reduce the administration's ability to negotiate agreements or do deals. They also yammer incessantly about phony Benghazi conspiracies, block confirmation of cabinet officials, ambassadors, and generally do what they can to make sure Obama lacks the time and energy to pursue Asian initiatives.
On Russia Haass notes that "U.S. and Western policy has not always encouraged more constructive choices on [Putin's] part". Republican Senator McCain is famous for suggesting that the U.S. get involved in a war between Georgia (the country, not the state) and Russia. This is typical of Republican opposition to "more constructive choices" that do not involve arming Russia's enemies.
More generally Haass laments that "attempts to construct new global arrangements to foster trade and frustrate climate change have foundered". The Republican party is home of (a) the "black helicopter" theory of the United Nations, (b) a legal theory that treaties signed by the President of the United States and ratified by the U.S. Senate do not have the force of law, (c) climate change denialism, (d) trilateral commission conspiracies, etc.
Then there is the list of Haass don'ts. "The gap between U.S. ambitions and U.S. actions needs to be narrowed." The home of the theory that U.S. power was unlimited as long as we were willing to put enough boots on the ground was the George W. Bush administration. President Obama strongly believes we can't do everything and is loudly and consistently criticized by Republicans for saying so. "Democratic transformations of other societies are often beyond the means of outsiders to achieve." Again, this is a lesson the Bush Administration never quite learned. They were the people that tried nation building in Iraq and Afghanistan at the same time. The war hawk wing of the Republican party seems to be impervious to this information. Haass criticizes Obama for his failure to achieve "a residual force" in Iraq. The deal that resulted in the withdrawal of forces from Iraq was a Bush deal. All Obama did was implement it. You can blame Obama for no residual forces in Afghanistan. But the primary reason seems to parallel Iraq, the locals want us out. And Obama has snuck 1,500 (with an additional 1,500 or more to likely follow) "advisors" back into Iraq, all with no congressional approval so far. If you like troops all over the place then Obama has done a much better job than the Republicans.
Generally speaking, Haass recommends that the goal of the U.S. should be "integration, trying to bring others into arrangements to manage global challenges such as climate change, terrorism, proliferation, trade, public health, and maintaining a secure and open commons". That sounds like a pretty good summary of the Obama foreign policy. I have highlighted Republican opposition to pretty much every item on this list above. Haass then moves on to a domestic perspective.
"The U.S. needs to put its domestic house in order". Specifically, "U.S. energy security has improved dramatically" and most of this improvement has happened on Obama's watch. On the other hand, oil imports grew under president Reagan and both presidents Bush. And now for the bad news, "the same cannot be said about other problems, such as the country's aging public infrastructure, its inadequate immigration policy, and its long term public finances". The Obama administration has proposed or implemented initiatives in all these areas. The Republicans do what they can to block or reduce them. They demonized the "stimulus", which contained substantial infrastructure spending. They have held up the highway bill and blocked or forced cutbacks other types of infrastructure spending. The Republicans in the House have blocked an Immigration Reform bill that had substantial Republican Senate support. Republicans have manufactured multiple crises around debt ceiling legislation and the budget. For several years now it has not been possible to proceed in the regular order on budget bills. Instead after a lot of grandstanding we end up with omnibus spending bills. This has been a long term embarrassment and has weakened the U.S. position in the world markedly.
Haass summarizes thusly: "In fact, sensible foreign and domestic policies are mutually reinforcing: a stable world is good for the home front, and a successful home front provides the resources needed for American global leadership." If we did this "[t]he good news is that the United States can afford both guns and butter". Unfortunately, Republicans seem hell bent on making sure we can afford neither. What can be more Anti-American than that.
There is also a strong case for my thesis based on GOP domestic policies. But, in order to constrain the discussion to a manageable scope, I am going to restrict myself to foreign affairs. And my starting point is an article by Richard Haass in the November/December issue of Foreign Affairs. In "The Unraveling", Mr. Haass takes a broad look at U.S. foreign policy and prescribes what he thinks should be done. For those of you not familiar with him, Mr. Haass is a long time figure in foreign policy circles. He is currently president of The Council on Foreign Relations. Before that he held positions in both the George H. W. Bush administration and that of his son. He is neither a right wing bomb thrower nor a left wing ideolog. He is a right leaning member of the establishment and, therefore, no friend of President Obama. In fact, he would characterize his piece as a critique of Obama's foreign policy. So let's see what he says and how this lines up with the pronouncements and actions of Republican politicians.
Mr. Haass sees the fundamental foreign policy issue as "a perennial tension in the world between the forces of order and the forces of disorder". Not surprisingly, he is in favor of order. He titles one section of his piece "The post-Cold War order is unraveling, and while not perfect, will be missed." He goes on to say "[t]hese days, the balance between order and disorder is shifting toward the latter. Some of the reasons are structural, but some are the result of bad choices made by important players -- and at least some of those can and should be corrected." My thesis in a nutshell is that Republicans are actively supporting these bad choices. So let's take a tour of the places Mr. Haass discusses and what he says should be done. Then let's see what Republicans are saying and doing.
He starts with the middle east. "In the Middle East, for example, order has been undermined by a tradition of top heavy, often corrupt, and illegitimate governments". He then lists their sins. So what's the U.S. contribution? "With more than a decade of hindsight, the decision to oust Saddam and remake Iraq looks even more mistaken than it did at the time." These actions were undertaken by a Republican administration with strong support up and down the party. And President Obama opposed it. So Obamas is on the right side of the argument and Republicans are on the wrong side. And remember, it is Haass who is providing the definition of what is right and what is wrong.
He then chastises the President for supporting the ousters in Libya and Egypt. Yet the governments of both countries fit Haass' definition of governments that have made things worse. So what, according to Haass, was the U.S. supposed to do? Were we to continue to support the old bad governments that were, according to the Haass definition, wrong governments? Yes! Apparently in both cases we should make an exception. So was their a strong argument for continued support of these old regimes by Republican politicians? No. Senator McCain and others were vigorously arguing for intervention, and earlier, and more of it. Elsewhere, Haass criticizes the U.S. "lack of effective follow-up". But it is at this point, when the Obama Administration was trying to impellent effective follow-up, that Republican support for intervention in these countries turned to opposition. The switch effectively sabotaged any chance for success.
Haass has something to say on Syria. He apparently approves of "support for the ouster of President Bashar al-Assad" but faults Obama for doing "little to bring it about". Here Republicans were loudly supportive of arming and supporting the "moderate opposition". We now know that the largest component of that opposition was what we now call ISIS/ISIL. Neither Haass nor the Republicans have given Obama any credit for pulling off the extremely tricky and difficult task of extracting large stockpiles of chemical weapons from an active war zone. Nor have they provided any useful help in identifying the "moderate" opposition or encouraging the Turks, Saudis, or other "moderate" Arab nations to participate in Syria in active and helpful ways. Instead, their contribution has consisted primarily of "whatever Obama is doing is wrong".
There was a time when the rule that said "politics stops at the water's edge". (The quotation is attributed to Republican Senator Vanderbilt in 1947.) There was a sound reason for this. As Haass says "[t]he world can see this", namely divisiveness around our foreign policy. This encourages the thinking in our opponents that "if we don't like what the current guys are offering we can just wait until the other guys get in and see if we can get a better deal from them". It also undermines the current administration's ability to make promises in order to secure a deal on some contentious issue. But the Republican party no longer feels bound by this rule. The Republicans may well block the implementation of the promise merely to score domestic political points. With this in mind, it is all the more impressive that Obama was able to bring the chemical weapons deal in Syria to a successful conclusion. No one should be in favor of a regime like Assad's having access to any chemical weapons, let alone the large stockpiles Assad had. Returning to Haass' piece, . . .
Haass makes note of and apparently approves of Obama's tilt toward Asia. His criticism here is "one of omission", that Obama hasn't sufficiently tilted. Have Republicans made a coherent argument, or for that matter any argument at all, that the tilt is a bad idea? No. But they have, as part of their general policy of "whatever Obama's for, we're against" policy, thrown roadblocks in the way where they could. They have tried to reduce the administration's ability to negotiate agreements or do deals. They also yammer incessantly about phony Benghazi conspiracies, block confirmation of cabinet officials, ambassadors, and generally do what they can to make sure Obama lacks the time and energy to pursue Asian initiatives.
On Russia Haass notes that "U.S. and Western policy has not always encouraged more constructive choices on [Putin's] part". Republican Senator McCain is famous for suggesting that the U.S. get involved in a war between Georgia (the country, not the state) and Russia. This is typical of Republican opposition to "more constructive choices" that do not involve arming Russia's enemies.
More generally Haass laments that "attempts to construct new global arrangements to foster trade and frustrate climate change have foundered". The Republican party is home of (a) the "black helicopter" theory of the United Nations, (b) a legal theory that treaties signed by the President of the United States and ratified by the U.S. Senate do not have the force of law, (c) climate change denialism, (d) trilateral commission conspiracies, etc.
Then there is the list of Haass don'ts. "The gap between U.S. ambitions and U.S. actions needs to be narrowed." The home of the theory that U.S. power was unlimited as long as we were willing to put enough boots on the ground was the George W. Bush administration. President Obama strongly believes we can't do everything and is loudly and consistently criticized by Republicans for saying so. "Democratic transformations of other societies are often beyond the means of outsiders to achieve." Again, this is a lesson the Bush Administration never quite learned. They were the people that tried nation building in Iraq and Afghanistan at the same time. The war hawk wing of the Republican party seems to be impervious to this information. Haass criticizes Obama for his failure to achieve "a residual force" in Iraq. The deal that resulted in the withdrawal of forces from Iraq was a Bush deal. All Obama did was implement it. You can blame Obama for no residual forces in Afghanistan. But the primary reason seems to parallel Iraq, the locals want us out. And Obama has snuck 1,500 (with an additional 1,500 or more to likely follow) "advisors" back into Iraq, all with no congressional approval so far. If you like troops all over the place then Obama has done a much better job than the Republicans.
Generally speaking, Haass recommends that the goal of the U.S. should be "integration, trying to bring others into arrangements to manage global challenges such as climate change, terrorism, proliferation, trade, public health, and maintaining a secure and open commons". That sounds like a pretty good summary of the Obama foreign policy. I have highlighted Republican opposition to pretty much every item on this list above. Haass then moves on to a domestic perspective.
"The U.S. needs to put its domestic house in order". Specifically, "U.S. energy security has improved dramatically" and most of this improvement has happened on Obama's watch. On the other hand, oil imports grew under president Reagan and both presidents Bush. And now for the bad news, "the same cannot be said about other problems, such as the country's aging public infrastructure, its inadequate immigration policy, and its long term public finances". The Obama administration has proposed or implemented initiatives in all these areas. The Republicans do what they can to block or reduce them. They demonized the "stimulus", which contained substantial infrastructure spending. They have held up the highway bill and blocked or forced cutbacks other types of infrastructure spending. The Republicans in the House have blocked an Immigration Reform bill that had substantial Republican Senate support. Republicans have manufactured multiple crises around debt ceiling legislation and the budget. For several years now it has not been possible to proceed in the regular order on budget bills. Instead after a lot of grandstanding we end up with omnibus spending bills. This has been a long term embarrassment and has weakened the U.S. position in the world markedly.
Haass summarizes thusly: "In fact, sensible foreign and domestic policies are mutually reinforcing: a stable world is good for the home front, and a successful home front provides the resources needed for American global leadership." If we did this "[t]he good news is that the United States can afford both guns and butter". Unfortunately, Republicans seem hell bent on making sure we can afford neither. What can be more Anti-American than that.
Saturday, October 25, 2014
Perry Mason - part 1
This is a post about the fictional Defense Attorney created by Erle Stanly Gardner. I am leaving the door open for additional future posts but I don't have any scheduled at this time. Manson's influence on culture and society is enormous. That's where I intend to focus. Let's start with the basics.
Gardner was a successful lawyer practicing in southern California. At some point he got a bad case of the writing bug. He experimented with a number of characters but zeroed in fairly quickly on Perry Mason. His first Mason novel was called "The Case of the Velvet Claw". It appeared in March of 1933. Gardner produced at least one and sometimes as many as four Mason novels a year right up to his death in 1970. Mason appeared in a number of additional forms including short stories and movies. But he was most successfully translated to the small screen. The "Perry Mason" TV show ran on CBS from 1957 to 1966. The series was resurrected in a series of made for TV movies that ran on NBC from 1985 to 1995. There have been other less successful TV outings that I am not going to list.
In the crime genre there is only one figure that has cast a larger shadow than Mason and that is Sherlock Holmes. The Mason stories built on the Holmes formula. They were in essence "puzzle" stories. Who did it and how? In the Holmes stories we start out having no idea who did it. The culprit is eventually revealed by Homes' crack detective work. Gardner put his own twist on the Holmes formula developed by Arthur Conan Doyle.
In the Doyle stories Holmes is a "Consulting Detective". He is most commonly brought in by someone associated with the crime. In other cases he is brought in by the authorities. Finally, Holmes sometimes injects himself into the situation for his own reasons. In the Gardner books Mason is always a practicing attorney. He almost always is representing a client. He will sometimes inject himself into a situation a la Holmes. But by the end he is representing someone as their attorney.
Again, Mason like Holmes, investigates. But where Homes depended primarily on his own investigative skill, Mason most often works through others. He starts with whatever the police and the Prosecuting Attorney's office is able to turn up. But he usually supplements this with the efforts of the Drake Detective Agency in general, and the agency's head, Paul Drake in particular. And he also sometimes casts his net even wider by using outside experts. Finally, he is not averse to doing a "Holmes" by personally investigating a crime scene or other important location. In contrast to Holmes, Mason is definitely not a lone wolf.
Holmes would typically restrict his activities to the investigative phase. When he decided that he had everything figured out he would turn the whole thing over to the authorities and take no further interest or action. Mason remained involved through court proceedings. He also effectively used examination and cross examination of witnesses who were in a courtroom situation under oath and with spectators and the press present to unearth critical evidence. Holmes is never seen in court and most of his activities are observed by Watson and perhaps the police, if they are observed at all.
Enough of the Holmes/Mason comparison. Let's look at more of the Mason formula. Here are some more components: (1) One way or another Mason always ends up with a client. (2) Mason's client is always charged with murder. (3) There is always a reasonable case to be made that Mason's client is guilty. (4) The case always goes to court. This sometimes involves a full trial. But in most cases the court proceeding is a preliminary hearing where a determination is to be made as to whether the defendant (Mason's client) is to be "bound over" to a full trial. The "preliminary" resembles a full trial in that witnesses are called, put under oath, examined, cross examined, and evidence is put into the record. But the outcome of the procedure is not a determination of guilt or innocence but a decision as to whether the defendant should be "bound over" or not. But, and this happens frequently in Mason cases, another possible outcome is for the charges to be dismissed and the defendant released. (5) Using various court room tactics Mason is able to (a) prove the defendant definitely did not commit the crime, and (b) some other specific person did.
There are some ancillary components to the Mason formula. They are: (6) Either the client or a close associate of the client has lots of money. This funds the efforts of Perry, the Drake agency, and whatever else is necessary to present a vigorous defense. Perry hangs out with the 1%-ers. (7) Perry makes heavy use of what used to be called "circumstantial" and is now called "physical" evidence. (8) The "lab work" or "expert analysis" of this physical evidence is always done competently. And the conclusion of the experts is always ultimately borne out. This pertains to fingerprints, gunshot residue, blood typing, bullet matching, etc. It also pertains to hair and fiber analysis. But hair and fiber analysis has since been shown to be problematic. Genetic testing of DNA extracted from hair roots is reliable. Examining the hair itself and extracting "identifying characteristics" has been shown to be bogus. There are also problems with fiber analysis (i.e. matching carpets). And the science of the day was not really up to trace analysis (i.e. stains on a piece of carpet). In spite of this, it turns out that the lab work is never done wrong in a Perry Mason story. (9) Perry is very good as a human lie detector. He invariably figures out who is lying and who is telling the truth. The only time Perry's lie detector sense fails him is when his client is telling the truth but the truth is unbelievable. Perry often incorrectly decides his client is lying to him when the client is telling the truth. Of course, eventually Perry figures out he was wrong and saves the day in the end. (10) Perry is a classic "father knows best" figure. What Perry decides is ultimately shown to be best and clients invariably get into trouble by not following Perry's instructions. Sometimes what Perry councils is ridiculous. But in the end (because that's how Gardner writes it) it will turn out that Perry's client would have been better off doing what Perry advised him to do. Finally, (11) It turns out that Perry's client is always innocent. Most people who are accused of a crime are guilty. And presumably we don't hear about the cases that Perry (a) turns down or (b) loses because his client is guilty or (c) worst yet wins in spite of the fact that his client is guilty.
So that's the formula. The Perry Mason books (and eventually TV shows, etc.) initially did a lot of good. When Gardner started writing police work was frankly not very professional. In large part it consisted of getting confessions, with a "rubber hose", if necessary. Gardner continued the trend pioneered by Doyle of basing police work on thorough investigation and the application of "scientific" techniques. And police work is now much more professional and we all benefit. There is still sloppy investigative work, work that is either done poorly or incompletely. And some "scientific" techniques like "forensic dentistry" have been found to be quackery. But scientific investigation, especially DNA based scientific investigation, has made great strides in convicting the guilty and clearing the innocent. This is all to the good.
But Mason is also a poster child for the "take no prisoners" approach to defending clients. The basic justification in Mason's case is that he is defending an innocent client. So "whatever is necessary" is justified. We the reader or viewer are eventually exposed to all the evidence in a Mason tale. Taken together that evidence indicates that Mason's client is innocent and some other specific person is guilty. But this is not the situation in the real world. A number of high profile attorneys specialize in this approach. Mason can justify his shenanigans because "they are necessary to expose the truth". But Gardner has contrived the situation so that "the truth" exonerates Perry's client. Mason always councils everyone to either say nothing or tell the truth. And Mason with his infallible (except as noted above) lie detector can invariably suss out the truth, which will invariably demonstrate the innocence of his client. It may be that all the truth must come out but that is a mere technicality that is overcome by Mason's clever work.
The problem is that the world that Mason inhabits is not the real world. In Mason's world all the pieces fit together and ultimately prove that his client is innocent. In the real world all the pieces do not fit together. There are gaps and inconsistencies. And all the facts will often convict the client an attorney is representing. So letting or even using various tricks to assist in getting all the facts out is not in the interest of the client and, therefore, not in the interest of the attorney. So how should an attorney represent a guilty client? Letting all the facts come out is a bad idea. Here's more to chew on.
Alan Dershowitz is a high powered attorney who teaches law at Harvard and does criminal defense work on the side. And, like Annalise Keating of the TV show "How to Get Away with Murder", he employs students from his classes to assist him in this defense work. He was part of the "dream team" of lawyers that represented O. J. Simpson in his murder trial. In his book "Reasonable Doubts" he says "My responsibility as a criminal defense lawyer is not to judge whether my client is innocent or guilty. Generally, I don't know. My job is to advocate zealously, within the rules. That's what I did in the Simpson case and I am proud of my work." Let me take this statement apart a bit.
Is it credible when he says "Generally, I don't know" with respect to the guilt or innocence of his client? No! Not to me. Mr. Dershowitz is a very smart man. He is there at ground level. He knows the evidence, all of the evidence that is introduced into the court proceedings, but also whatever evidence his team unearthed and chose not to present, and some or all of the evidence that the other side unearthed but did not present. So he has a ring side seat and a lot of skill to apply to the problem. And the result is "I don't know". I don't think so. Now there are several possible interpretations of "I don't know" that might restore Mr. Dershowitz's credibility. If you read his book it becomes obvious that by "innocent" Dershowitz really means "not convicted". If the prosecution is unable to get a conviction, regardless of the reason, then the client is "innocent". This is a ridiculous perspective for an ordinary person but an entirely sensible one for a criminal defense lawyer. He could also be engaging in a voluntary suspension of disbelief for the duration of the proceedings. Again this is a reasonable approach for a criminal defense attorney to deploy. So I could buy this, except for one thing.
Dershowitz goes to great lengths to trash the reputation of a cop by the name of Philip Vannatter. He thinks Vannatter is a professional liar. And what is his big lie? That when he originally approached the Simpson residence he did not at that time think Simpson was a suspect, or so he testifies. It seems to me that Alan Deshowitz thinks he can not know whether his client is guilty or innocent even though he is thoroughly familiar with the case. Mr. Vannatter, however, is not capable of similar mental gymnastics with respect to Mr. Simpson's guilt or innocence when he was initially approaching the residence, at least in the same Mr. Dershowitz's considered opinion.. At that time evidence one way or the other was sparse. There was certainly evidence that pointed toward Simpson. But at that point it was entirely possible that additional evidence would develop that would point away from Mr. Simpson and toward another party. So why after completing a very thorough preparation for a trial can Mr. Dershowitz "don't know" whether his client is guilty or not but at an early stage of a developing investigation is Mr. Vannatter is incapable of a similar "don't know"? At that point Mr. Desshowitz's credibility is shot as far as I am concerned.
There is a real quandary here. If a defense attorney concludes his client is guilty how should he comport himself? He has an obligation to his client and to justice. Justice demands that the prosecution actually present a case that actually demonstrates that the defendant is guilty "beyond a reasonable doubt" in criminal cases. (The bar is the lower "by a preponderance of the evidence" in civil cases.) It is the responsibility of the defense attorney to make sure that the prosecution dots all the "i"s and crosses all the "t"s. And the defendant should get off if the prosecution fails. But, as Mr. Deshowitz compellingly argues, this leaves the defendant in a bad place. "Everybody knows he did it and got away with it." That's bad. Mason always ends up showing that the defendant is cleanly and clearly innocent. That's a much better place to leave the defendant. And people are very good at picking up when a defense attorney is putting on a "my client is innocent" case versus a "the prosecution didn't prove my client is guilty" case. The former, if possible, is much preferable to the latter.
We can see this playing out in the Simpson case. You can make an argument, and Dershowitz does, that Simpson should not have been convicted based on the case the prosecution actually presented. But I think from the present distance a consensus has formed that Simpson got off as opposed to being entirely innocent. I have contended elsewhere (http://sigma5.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-oj-trial.html) that the Simpson verdict was wrong but not awful. But my position is in the minority. And Simpson has suffered greatly by the consensus view that he did it. Dershowitz advocates always putting on a "Perry Mason" style defense as this is the best way to avoid a Simpson-like result. But part and parcel with this thinking is resort to Mason style tactics. So you have "take no prisoners" defenses. But the justification for "take no prisoners" is usually missing. And the only people who can afford a "take no prisoners" defense are the wealthy or the powerful.
The Simpson trial exposed some serious flaws in, for instance, the Los Angelis Police Department. And these flaws extended to both patrol officers and the crime lab. Improving both as a result of the Simpson trial, if it happened, would definitely be a good thing. But the result is also long drawn out trials where everything is fought over. But in the case of most trials both the prosecution and the defense are under resourced. The rules that courts operate under have to take this into account. But an "all out" defense can and does take advantage of these rules. So all of a sudden all court cases become longer, more complicated, and more expensive. This is a bad thing. And, since poor people can't afford to mount this kind of defense, they literally are subjected to a different justice system than the well off and powerful. Perry Mason, by laying out how to conduct a "take no prisoners" defense and by providing a justification for it based largely on fiction, has contributed to the injustice of it all. Cops and prosecutors misbehave. But this misbehavior is rarely brought to light by these high profile trials. In fact, people look at something like the Simpson trial and conclude that the system is rigged in favor of the other guy. And that too is a bad thing.
Gardner was a successful lawyer practicing in southern California. At some point he got a bad case of the writing bug. He experimented with a number of characters but zeroed in fairly quickly on Perry Mason. His first Mason novel was called "The Case of the Velvet Claw". It appeared in March of 1933. Gardner produced at least one and sometimes as many as four Mason novels a year right up to his death in 1970. Mason appeared in a number of additional forms including short stories and movies. But he was most successfully translated to the small screen. The "Perry Mason" TV show ran on CBS from 1957 to 1966. The series was resurrected in a series of made for TV movies that ran on NBC from 1985 to 1995. There have been other less successful TV outings that I am not going to list.
In the crime genre there is only one figure that has cast a larger shadow than Mason and that is Sherlock Holmes. The Mason stories built on the Holmes formula. They were in essence "puzzle" stories. Who did it and how? In the Holmes stories we start out having no idea who did it. The culprit is eventually revealed by Homes' crack detective work. Gardner put his own twist on the Holmes formula developed by Arthur Conan Doyle.
In the Doyle stories Holmes is a "Consulting Detective". He is most commonly brought in by someone associated with the crime. In other cases he is brought in by the authorities. Finally, Holmes sometimes injects himself into the situation for his own reasons. In the Gardner books Mason is always a practicing attorney. He almost always is representing a client. He will sometimes inject himself into a situation a la Holmes. But by the end he is representing someone as their attorney.
Again, Mason like Holmes, investigates. But where Homes depended primarily on his own investigative skill, Mason most often works through others. He starts with whatever the police and the Prosecuting Attorney's office is able to turn up. But he usually supplements this with the efforts of the Drake Detective Agency in general, and the agency's head, Paul Drake in particular. And he also sometimes casts his net even wider by using outside experts. Finally, he is not averse to doing a "Holmes" by personally investigating a crime scene or other important location. In contrast to Holmes, Mason is definitely not a lone wolf.
Holmes would typically restrict his activities to the investigative phase. When he decided that he had everything figured out he would turn the whole thing over to the authorities and take no further interest or action. Mason remained involved through court proceedings. He also effectively used examination and cross examination of witnesses who were in a courtroom situation under oath and with spectators and the press present to unearth critical evidence. Holmes is never seen in court and most of his activities are observed by Watson and perhaps the police, if they are observed at all.
Enough of the Holmes/Mason comparison. Let's look at more of the Mason formula. Here are some more components: (1) One way or another Mason always ends up with a client. (2) Mason's client is always charged with murder. (3) There is always a reasonable case to be made that Mason's client is guilty. (4) The case always goes to court. This sometimes involves a full trial. But in most cases the court proceeding is a preliminary hearing where a determination is to be made as to whether the defendant (Mason's client) is to be "bound over" to a full trial. The "preliminary" resembles a full trial in that witnesses are called, put under oath, examined, cross examined, and evidence is put into the record. But the outcome of the procedure is not a determination of guilt or innocence but a decision as to whether the defendant should be "bound over" or not. But, and this happens frequently in Mason cases, another possible outcome is for the charges to be dismissed and the defendant released. (5) Using various court room tactics Mason is able to (a) prove the defendant definitely did not commit the crime, and (b) some other specific person did.
There are some ancillary components to the Mason formula. They are: (6) Either the client or a close associate of the client has lots of money. This funds the efforts of Perry, the Drake agency, and whatever else is necessary to present a vigorous defense. Perry hangs out with the 1%-ers. (7) Perry makes heavy use of what used to be called "circumstantial" and is now called "physical" evidence. (8) The "lab work" or "expert analysis" of this physical evidence is always done competently. And the conclusion of the experts is always ultimately borne out. This pertains to fingerprints, gunshot residue, blood typing, bullet matching, etc. It also pertains to hair and fiber analysis. But hair and fiber analysis has since been shown to be problematic. Genetic testing of DNA extracted from hair roots is reliable. Examining the hair itself and extracting "identifying characteristics" has been shown to be bogus. There are also problems with fiber analysis (i.e. matching carpets). And the science of the day was not really up to trace analysis (i.e. stains on a piece of carpet). In spite of this, it turns out that the lab work is never done wrong in a Perry Mason story. (9) Perry is very good as a human lie detector. He invariably figures out who is lying and who is telling the truth. The only time Perry's lie detector sense fails him is when his client is telling the truth but the truth is unbelievable. Perry often incorrectly decides his client is lying to him when the client is telling the truth. Of course, eventually Perry figures out he was wrong and saves the day in the end. (10) Perry is a classic "father knows best" figure. What Perry decides is ultimately shown to be best and clients invariably get into trouble by not following Perry's instructions. Sometimes what Perry councils is ridiculous. But in the end (because that's how Gardner writes it) it will turn out that Perry's client would have been better off doing what Perry advised him to do. Finally, (11) It turns out that Perry's client is always innocent. Most people who are accused of a crime are guilty. And presumably we don't hear about the cases that Perry (a) turns down or (b) loses because his client is guilty or (c) worst yet wins in spite of the fact that his client is guilty.
So that's the formula. The Perry Mason books (and eventually TV shows, etc.) initially did a lot of good. When Gardner started writing police work was frankly not very professional. In large part it consisted of getting confessions, with a "rubber hose", if necessary. Gardner continued the trend pioneered by Doyle of basing police work on thorough investigation and the application of "scientific" techniques. And police work is now much more professional and we all benefit. There is still sloppy investigative work, work that is either done poorly or incompletely. And some "scientific" techniques like "forensic dentistry" have been found to be quackery. But scientific investigation, especially DNA based scientific investigation, has made great strides in convicting the guilty and clearing the innocent. This is all to the good.
But Mason is also a poster child for the "take no prisoners" approach to defending clients. The basic justification in Mason's case is that he is defending an innocent client. So "whatever is necessary" is justified. We the reader or viewer are eventually exposed to all the evidence in a Mason tale. Taken together that evidence indicates that Mason's client is innocent and some other specific person is guilty. But this is not the situation in the real world. A number of high profile attorneys specialize in this approach. Mason can justify his shenanigans because "they are necessary to expose the truth". But Gardner has contrived the situation so that "the truth" exonerates Perry's client. Mason always councils everyone to either say nothing or tell the truth. And Mason with his infallible (except as noted above) lie detector can invariably suss out the truth, which will invariably demonstrate the innocence of his client. It may be that all the truth must come out but that is a mere technicality that is overcome by Mason's clever work.
The problem is that the world that Mason inhabits is not the real world. In Mason's world all the pieces fit together and ultimately prove that his client is innocent. In the real world all the pieces do not fit together. There are gaps and inconsistencies. And all the facts will often convict the client an attorney is representing. So letting or even using various tricks to assist in getting all the facts out is not in the interest of the client and, therefore, not in the interest of the attorney. So how should an attorney represent a guilty client? Letting all the facts come out is a bad idea. Here's more to chew on.
Alan Dershowitz is a high powered attorney who teaches law at Harvard and does criminal defense work on the side. And, like Annalise Keating of the TV show "How to Get Away with Murder", he employs students from his classes to assist him in this defense work. He was part of the "dream team" of lawyers that represented O. J. Simpson in his murder trial. In his book "Reasonable Doubts" he says "My responsibility as a criminal defense lawyer is not to judge whether my client is innocent or guilty. Generally, I don't know. My job is to advocate zealously, within the rules. That's what I did in the Simpson case and I am proud of my work." Let me take this statement apart a bit.
Is it credible when he says "Generally, I don't know" with respect to the guilt or innocence of his client? No! Not to me. Mr. Dershowitz is a very smart man. He is there at ground level. He knows the evidence, all of the evidence that is introduced into the court proceedings, but also whatever evidence his team unearthed and chose not to present, and some or all of the evidence that the other side unearthed but did not present. So he has a ring side seat and a lot of skill to apply to the problem. And the result is "I don't know". I don't think so. Now there are several possible interpretations of "I don't know" that might restore Mr. Dershowitz's credibility. If you read his book it becomes obvious that by "innocent" Dershowitz really means "not convicted". If the prosecution is unable to get a conviction, regardless of the reason, then the client is "innocent". This is a ridiculous perspective for an ordinary person but an entirely sensible one for a criminal defense lawyer. He could also be engaging in a voluntary suspension of disbelief for the duration of the proceedings. Again this is a reasonable approach for a criminal defense attorney to deploy. So I could buy this, except for one thing.
Dershowitz goes to great lengths to trash the reputation of a cop by the name of Philip Vannatter. He thinks Vannatter is a professional liar. And what is his big lie? That when he originally approached the Simpson residence he did not at that time think Simpson was a suspect, or so he testifies. It seems to me that Alan Deshowitz thinks he can not know whether his client is guilty or innocent even though he is thoroughly familiar with the case. Mr. Vannatter, however, is not capable of similar mental gymnastics with respect to Mr. Simpson's guilt or innocence when he was initially approaching the residence, at least in the same Mr. Dershowitz's considered opinion.. At that time evidence one way or the other was sparse. There was certainly evidence that pointed toward Simpson. But at that point it was entirely possible that additional evidence would develop that would point away from Mr. Simpson and toward another party. So why after completing a very thorough preparation for a trial can Mr. Dershowitz "don't know" whether his client is guilty or not but at an early stage of a developing investigation is Mr. Vannatter is incapable of a similar "don't know"? At that point Mr. Desshowitz's credibility is shot as far as I am concerned.
There is a real quandary here. If a defense attorney concludes his client is guilty how should he comport himself? He has an obligation to his client and to justice. Justice demands that the prosecution actually present a case that actually demonstrates that the defendant is guilty "beyond a reasonable doubt" in criminal cases. (The bar is the lower "by a preponderance of the evidence" in civil cases.) It is the responsibility of the defense attorney to make sure that the prosecution dots all the "i"s and crosses all the "t"s. And the defendant should get off if the prosecution fails. But, as Mr. Deshowitz compellingly argues, this leaves the defendant in a bad place. "Everybody knows he did it and got away with it." That's bad. Mason always ends up showing that the defendant is cleanly and clearly innocent. That's a much better place to leave the defendant. And people are very good at picking up when a defense attorney is putting on a "my client is innocent" case versus a "the prosecution didn't prove my client is guilty" case. The former, if possible, is much preferable to the latter.
We can see this playing out in the Simpson case. You can make an argument, and Dershowitz does, that Simpson should not have been convicted based on the case the prosecution actually presented. But I think from the present distance a consensus has formed that Simpson got off as opposed to being entirely innocent. I have contended elsewhere (http://sigma5.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-oj-trial.html) that the Simpson verdict was wrong but not awful. But my position is in the minority. And Simpson has suffered greatly by the consensus view that he did it. Dershowitz advocates always putting on a "Perry Mason" style defense as this is the best way to avoid a Simpson-like result. But part and parcel with this thinking is resort to Mason style tactics. So you have "take no prisoners" defenses. But the justification for "take no prisoners" is usually missing. And the only people who can afford a "take no prisoners" defense are the wealthy or the powerful.
The Simpson trial exposed some serious flaws in, for instance, the Los Angelis Police Department. And these flaws extended to both patrol officers and the crime lab. Improving both as a result of the Simpson trial, if it happened, would definitely be a good thing. But the result is also long drawn out trials where everything is fought over. But in the case of most trials both the prosecution and the defense are under resourced. The rules that courts operate under have to take this into account. But an "all out" defense can and does take advantage of these rules. So all of a sudden all court cases become longer, more complicated, and more expensive. This is a bad thing. And, since poor people can't afford to mount this kind of defense, they literally are subjected to a different justice system than the well off and powerful. Perry Mason, by laying out how to conduct a "take no prisoners" defense and by providing a justification for it based largely on fiction, has contributed to the injustice of it all. Cops and prosecutors misbehave. But this misbehavior is rarely brought to light by these high profile trials. In fact, people look at something like the Simpson trial and conclude that the system is rigged in favor of the other guy. And that too is a bad thing.
Tuesday, October 21, 2014
Ebola! Panic! - or not
The bottom line here is to head the advice from "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" by Douglas Adams. The advice is simple: Don't Panic. For the last several weeks we have been getting the opposite advice. We have been told by many august personages on many occasions not only to Panic! But to PANIC!!! But in the last day or so I have detected indications that things are about to change. I have even seen some indications it is already starting. The new message is the proper one, namely don't panic. It would be nice if the "don't panic" message is given prominence equal to that of the old "panic" message. Instead, if the past is any indication, the message on Ebola will instead change to silence. Rather than rehash what has already been hashed (i.e. "don't panic" was always the correct message) I am going to delve into two subjects. The first is why we have been hearing "panic" so loudly and from so many quarters. Ebola has only actually affected a few people in the U.S. to date. It's hard to justify all the outcry. But what if an epidemic eventually developed? Then it might be not unreasonable to panic. Rather than debate the issue I am instead going to look at how an epidemic could be handled to see if even this scenario justifies any of the hype. Proceeding . . .
There is a sophisticated and powerful entity at work in our culture. I am going to call it Fear, Inc. If you check with the Securities and Exchange Commission you will not find a company of that name listed. That's because it is an informal group acting in concert rather than an actual company. The name is an homage to Murder, Inc., another organization that was never incorporated. In the case of Murder, Inc. there was an actual group of specific people who identified with the name. It was the nickname used by a group of contract killers that worked for the mob in the '30s and '40s. Together they were purported to be responsible for between 100 and 500 murders. The group was ultimately broken up by a concerted effort by the federal government. Thomas E. Dewey was one of the government men who was part of the effort. He parlayed the notoriety he gained from busting up Murder, Inc. into a run for President as the candidate of the a Republican party.
With Murder Inc. were specific people you could point to. If you asked them and got an honest answer they would admit to being members of Murder, Inc. In some cases they would even see it as a source of pride. The membership in Fear, Inc. is much more widespread. And, like Murder, Inc. it is possible to identify members or the organization. But the members of Fear Inc. would vehemently deny being a member. In some cases they would go so far at to accuse others of being members. So while no one is willing to admit to being a part of Fear, Inc.there is definitely a fear industry. And while they might wish to decline the offer, I am willing to call people who do the work of the fear industry members of Fear, Inc. They deserve the accolade as much or more as the members of Murder, Inc. did. So who are these people? They are politicians and members of the news media. Let me start with an explanation of how this works when it comes to politicians.
At least theoretically in the old days politics was a "may the best man (it used to be all men) win" competition. On the other hand, Finley Peter Dunne in an 1895 newspaper column observed that "politics ain't beanbag". But for a long time afterward there still seemed to be an agreed on set of rules to the game. And one rule required everybody to at least pretended that political campaigns were about the great issues of the day and not trivia. That is manifestly no longer true today. In the past few days there has been a tornado of coverage concerning the fact that one candidate for the governorship of Florida likes to use a small fan to keep cool at political events. Coverage of the issues this contest should be about is conspicuous by its absence. And that's just one example of dozens I could point to. A lot of political coverage is about trivia and not about the great issues of the day. There is a new book out by Matt Bai called "All the Truth is Out: The Week Politics Went Tabloid". I have not read the book but I have heard good things about it. Bei contends that a substantial shift away from issues and toward trivia happened in a single specific week. I am not interested in the how or the when of this shift. I am only interested in the fact that it has happened.
With that as background consider two candidates: Smith and Jones. Both of them are vying for some political position. Both are human so both have flaws. Let's say you are Smith and Jones seems to be the better candidate when viewed through the lens of "the great issues of the day". What do you do? Most people do not put a lot of effort into picking a candidate to vote for. And if a candidate does a lot of "right" things but does one thing you think is very wrong what do you do? Well, in election after election in my experience, you vote for the other guy. You do this in spite of the fact that the other guy does a lot of wrong things. All that is necessary for things to work this way is for you to not have your nose rubbed in the wrong things the other guy does. This observation leads to the solution to Smith's problem.
Let's say you can pin something on your opponent. Let's say you can make that thing sound like a "terrible, horrible, no good, very bad" (to steal from a movie title) thing. And let's say your opponent fails to do the same thing back to you. Then you have the election in the bag. So is my analysis correct? It doesn't matter because political consultants believe it's true. So they advise candidates to "go negative", to find something that you can be pined on your opponent and make him or her sound "terrible, . . .". As just one example of this let me go all the way back to 1960 and the Kennedy/Nixon race for President. The conventional wisdom is that Kennedy won the TV version of the first debate because Nixon looked like he had a 5 o'clock shadow. The conventional wisdom also says that people listening to the same debate on the radio thought Nixon won it. That election was close and conventional wisdom says that the "5 o'clock shadow" debate tipped it to Kennedy. Once an idea like this gets established then people behave like it's true and whether it is actually true or not is longer important.
Now let's also say that voters think a particular election is not very important. They might think "there's not a dime's worth of difference between my two choices", for instance. What do voters who think like this do? Well, a lot of them stay home. It doesn't do a candidate any good to convince a voter she is the right candidate if that voter doesn't actually vote. But let's say that in a particular race one candidate is a bland nonentity but the other candidate is a "terrible, horrible, no good, very bad" candidate. Then voters who think like this will show up at the polls and vote reliably for the bland candidate. Why? Fear! They are afraid the "terrible, . . ." candidate will win and this, of course, will result in "terrible, . . ." things happening. If you want someone to actually do something specific then fear of a bad thing happening is a much more effective motivator than something where one of two things can happen and neither thing is very bad. This is true even if one of the things is much better than the other. Politicians, or more importantly their consultants, have figured this out. And this is why elections are so negative. Scaring voters into being afraid of your opponent is much more effective than convincing them of your wonderfulness.
And this is why political campaigns have become so horrible. Everyone hates them. Voters would much rather vote for some positive good thing than otherwise. Campaigns are designed to convince voters that one candidate is wonderful and the other candidate is horrible. But the efforts of each campaign to convince voters that the other guy is horrible are more effective than their campaign to convince voters that their guy is wonderful. This results an voters deciding both candidates are horrible, becoming disgusted with the whole business, and in many cases staying home. "A pox on both their houses." Nobody has figured out how to get out of this box. So all candidates are merchants of fear. They feel they have to do it to win elections. And if they can convince voters that the other candidate is to be feared and they are not to be feared then they are right. They will win the election.
A case can be made that some candidates or parties rely more heavily on fear than others. But everyone does it. And, of course, what works as an election strategy unfortunately is also applied to governance. Once a candidate is elected she wants to be seen as effective. Again there are tons of good things she can do. But voters don't remember. What they do remember is when you saved them from that "terrible, horrible, no good, very bad" thing happening. Again, it doesn't matter if it is actually "terrible, . . .". It only maters if you can sell the story that it is "terrible, . . .". So in the little time not devoted to fund raising for the next election, and there is almost always a next election, politicians search for and try to exploit whatever "terrible, . . ." thing comes their way. So that's why politicians carry water for Fear, Inc. Why does the news media?
Well, in a lot of ways the news media has the same problem politicians have. With politicians it's black and white. Either you win the election or you lose it. With the media it is shades of grey. But it ends up the same. You see the news media's job is not to tell you as clearly and as well as they can what's going on with an accent on the important stuff. The news media's job is to attract eyeballs so that their endeavors will result in high ad rates. The news media is in a continuous election situation. They win or lose not based on how many votes they get but on what their Neilson numbers are, or their subscription numbers are, or how many "click throughs" they get. And here too fear works. You have your choice of TV shows to watch or Internet channels to follow or newspapers to read. And in each case you also have the chance of "staying home" by not watching or following or reading the paper.
Again, harkening to a previous era, if you see a newspaper on a news stand and there is a three inch headline that says "WAR" are you going to buy the paper? Of course you are. Similarly, if you see a "WAR" banner on a web site you are certainly going to click through. War is a very frightening event. Now what happens if you see a much smaller headline saying "GDP up for fifth straight quarter" (definitely good news) or "talks stretch into third straight week" (neutral news), then what? You might decide to check in later or skip it altogether. And a decision like that, if repeated by many others, results in depressed ratings, clicks, or circulation. News organizations don't like that.
The history of CNN's rating bears this out. If there is a big story like a war their ratings go up. If it is a "slow news day" their ratings go down. And people are attracted to bad news more strongly than good. So it is in the economic interest of news organizations to convince the public that something bad has just happened or is about to happen. And, as with politicians, it doesn't much matter what the actual importance of the bad news is. It is only important that the public can be convinced that whatever it is, it's bad, very bad. The importance of finding "important" bad news has long since filtered down to front line reporters. They all know their job is to make "it", whatever "it" is, sound very bad. The reporters that don't "get the memo" either don't last long or they end up at news organizations no one has heard of.
Ebola falls squarely into this category. As I write this exactly one person has died in the U.S. and only a handful have contracted the disease. For comparison I checked out the "Around the Northwest" section of The Seattle Times, my local newspaper, for one day. I picked Saturday October 18 because nothing particular was going on. This feature is a collection of short items of interest (in the opinion of the editorial staff) to readers but which are not sufficiently important to rate a stand alone story. To give you an idea of what I'm talking about the feature takes up less than a whole page and appeared on page B-4 that day. However, this one selection from an unimportant part of the paper for one ordinary day gave details on three deaths. So the death of one person on one day across the entire United States should not be that big a deal. But vast amounts of coverage have been devoted to Ebola in the U.S. Currently there are a small number (less than ten) of other people in the U.S. who have been diagnosed with Ebola. But there is a good chance that all of them will live.
So the "Ebola in the U.S." story has been massively over-covered. And it has all been heavily laden with a "be afraid, be very afraid" subtext. In fact, in a lot of cases the "text" has been less than "sub". It has been blatant. And every wing and branch of the media has been guilty of fear mongering. Some outlets have been more guilty (Fox and other right wing outlets) but everybody has been doing it. One trick a lot of TV news uses is to have the talking head say the right things while video of ambulances and other scary stuff runs in the background. Another piece of conventional wisdom holds that pictures, particularly moving pictures (and the video they use always has a lot of movement in it) trump whatever the talking head is saying. So these other less-blatant outlets are just using a more subtle technique to scare us to death. And they can pull the trick off of getting the ratings while maintaining the fiction that they are responsible journalists. "Nice work, if you can get it, and you can get it if you try."
So politicians and the media are selling us fear. Why is it working? At some level everyone knows that one death and a handful of sick people are not that scary. Sure, there is great video of emergency vehicles running around with lots of lights flashing and people walking around in moon suits. I admit that's "compelling", as in "good for ratings" video. But it's not enough. So why did it work? In a word, epidemic.
If one person can die and a bunch of people can get sick what happens if a whole lot of people get sick? If we ignore the experts who claim it won't happen and assume it happens anyhow, what happens? "We're all going to die!", that's what happens. This is the fear mother load. "Responsible" journalists don't go there. Instead they drum up every tiny nugget of "some expert got it wrong" they can find and let people fill in the blanks. I am not going to rehash all the reasons why an epidemic is not going to happen. Instead I am just going to cut to the chase. I am going to assume that somehow an Ebola epidemic breaks out. We have thousands of people getting sick all over the place. What then?
Now that I have you on the edge of your seat I am going to make a digression. Early in my career I worked with a lot of IBM equipment and people. I got to know how IBM operated. The IBM of that period was a classic "not invented here" organization. To IBM's way of thinking if it wasn't invented or developed inside IBM it was no good. IBM was very successful for a long time with "not invented here". It was finally forced to change in the early '80s when it brought out the IBM PC, which was composed of parts (both hardware and software) that were, in fact, invented somewhere else. And those same Fear, Inc. yahoos, politicians and the media are now fierce proponents of "not invented here". Ebola was beneath notice as long as it was happening in Africa. Hundreds then thousands of deaths - not a problem. It's happening way over there. Ebola only became worthy of notice when it washed up on our shores.
That's bad. But what is worse is that our response to Ebola has suffered, and badly, from a serious case of "not invented here". Africa has been dealing with Ebola for decades. There have been dozens of outbreaks. They have all been contained. Is this current outbreak somehow different than the previous ones? Yes! But the differences are ones of scale rather than kind. This time Ebola broke out in countries that had non-existent medical systems. They also had poor to non-existent communications, roads, etc. So Ebola could break out and spread widely before anyone even knew anything was going on. When they did recognize they had a problem they lacked the resources to deal with it. Ebola is a problem in Africa not because no one knows what to do. It is a problem because no one has the resources to do what needs to be done. But that is all happening over there. So we flounder around trying to figure out what to do without making a serious effort to find out what they did over there that worked. A polite version of what we did instead goes by the phrase "reinventing the wheel". Why? Because judging by our actions we believe we are smart and special and everyone else is dumb and ordinary.
So let's say a large epidemic of Ebola broke out in the U.S. What should we do? Well, there's U.S. Ebola response, version 1. This is what Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital did. That resulted in patient zero dying and two health workers getting infected. So let's not do that. Then there's U.S. Ebola response version 2. The virtue of version 2 is that it's working. We have a small number of facilities that are set up to handle the most contagious diseases. So far no one treated at one of these facilities has died. And so far no one has caught Ebola at one of these facilities from the patients they are treating. These are both good things. The problem is that there are only four of these facilities and they can only handle about ten patients between them. If we have hundreds or thousands of infected people that's not going to work either. So we now move on to what I think a successful system for dealing with large numbers of Ebola patients would look like. Call it version 3.
And version 3 is based on what worked in Africa. Two countries in Africa have successfully eliminated Ebola after having had at least one case. If they can do it, we should be able to. Both of these countries are third world countries. What separates them from the countries where Ebola is endemic is that they both have primitive but functioning health care systems. All the countries where Ebola is raging are countries that recently emerged from civil war. Whatever health care system they had was wiped out by the war. The fact that there was no health care system to build on is what has made it so hard for these countries to get a handle on Ebola. But if you talk to the right people in Africa you can find out how to successfully defeat Ebola.
And it turns out that you don't really have to go to Africa. Doctors Without Borders is the U.S. branch of an international organization headquartered in France. Doctors Without Borders knows how to successfully deal with Ebola patients. Then there's the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation. An operation funded and organized by the Gates Foundation was the key to wiping Ebola out in Nigeria. So "who are you going to call?" Call the Gates Foundation or Doctors Without Borders. Pick whichever one you want or call both of them.
I have not actually called either of them. But if you poke around enough you can find out what they would say if you did call them. And here's the formula:
Step 1 - diagnosis. People who are not actively symptomatic are not dangerous. If a person is not running a temperature they are safe. So monitor people's temperature. There has been an argument about what the critical temperature is and people have said that the CDC screwed up by letting one of the current patients fly. She had a temperature but it was below the threshold. And at the time she had that temperature she probably was not dangerous. Her temperature later rose quite a bit and she came down with the disease. But so far none of the people on the plane with her have come down with the disease. (It is too soon to be 100% sure no one will come down but I'm betting none of them will.) The other thing to remember is there is a test for Ebola. The test doesn't take very long to get a result. But a person in early stages tests negative. Of course, at that point they are also not dangerous. I don't know if we have a lot of test kits. If we don't this could be a serious problem in an epidemic situation.
Step 2 - Isolation. We are currently using high end isolation units. That works but we only have a few. The "isolation" Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital used was ineffective. As is common, the media provides few in any details. But I suspect that the nurses that got infected had the wrong kind of protective gear or used it incorrectly. I do not fault them. As far as I can tell both of them followed directions. But what the Africa experience tells us is that all skin must be covered. The disease is transmitted by skin contact with infected bodily fluids (sweat, diarrhea, vomit, etc.). Some reports indicate their necks were exposed. The Africa experience also tells us that it is very difficult to properly disrobe. If infected bodily fluid on the outside of the protective gear ends up in contact with your skin you can get infected. The Africa experience recommends training and a buddy system. Your buddy verifies that you have donned and most importantly doffed your protective gear properly. My understanding is that the nurses were not using the buddy system. The gloves, moon suits, etc. are broadly available and can be procured in large numbers. The proper technique can be taught and adopting the buddy system is a matter of procedure. So all this can be easily scaled up to large numbers.
Step 3 - Disinfection part 1. It turns out that the virus is easy to kill. A chlorine solution works pretty well. So is a chlorine solution hard to come by? No! It's what you find in every swimming pool and hot tub. You can go to any Home and Garden store or Spa store and buy large bags of the proper chemical. And a single bag of the chemical goes a long way. You also need a sprayer. A bug sprayer from any Home and Garden story will do just fine. Part of the Isolation/Disinfection problem is where do you put all these sick people? Initially all the infected people of Texas Health Presbyterian were put in standard isolation rooms. That didn't work. So do we need to go all high tech like the units we are currently using? No! Tents in a field will work fine. That makes it easy to physically separate each patient and provide paths the care givers can use to go about their business while being physically separated from the source of the infection most of the time. We have lots of fields. And we have lots of tents. The Africa experience also recommends gravel. Why? Because they recommend a lot of sluicing people and things down with the chlorinated water. If the ground is gravel then everything drains away where no one can step on it.
Step 4 - disinfection part 2. People who get really sick with Ebola generate a large volume of bodily fluids. They can get a bad case of diarrhea. They can vomit a lot. They can sweat a lot. They can toss and turn a lot. So there is a lot of dangerous material generated. And this can get smeared around a lot. It can get on the clothes of the patient, the bed linen, the moon suit, anything else in the vicinity of the patient. You take all this together and there is a large volume of contaminated stuff to deal with. Texan health Presbyterian is rumored to have filled a room completely full of contaminated stuff. The Africa experience recommends burning all of it. This is harder to do than it would seem. You need to make sure no contaminated surface comes into contact with anything it's not supposed to. If you get all the contaminated material safely into the "burn box" of the incinerator (a high tech fire place) and you burn it all up then everything is fine.
One of our high tech isolation facilities uses a different solution. They autoclave everything. So what's an autoclave? It is a high tech pressure cooker that was invented about 150 years ago. It turns out there are some viruses (Ebola is not one of them) that can survive normal steam at 212 degrees Fahrenheit. An autoclave is a pressure container. You put some water and whatever you want to sterilize inside and fire it up. It heats the water under pressure. This lets the temperature rise to well over 212 thus killing everything. This idea of autoclaving everything works just fine. And there are a lot of autoclaves around if you look hard enough. But is there a third option that is less drastic than burning everything and easier to do than autoclaving everything? I think so. Get a back yard type inflatable swimming pool. Inflate it and fill it with chlorinated water. Then dump stuff in it like bed clothes, moon suits, whatever. Stir everything around thoroughly, say for 20 minutes. I think this would work fine. But if anybody has tested this I don't know about it. So this technique should only be tried if it turns out you can't burn everything or autoclave everything. But I bet it would work. It has the virtue of being a simple, cheap, high volume solution.
We are now done if all we want to do is stop the epidemic. Of course, a lot of our patients will die. So how about actually treating out patients and trying to save their lives? This is not necessary to stop the epidemic but it seems like a good idea if we can pull it off. Based on what we now know it may not be possible to save everyone. In the primitive conditions in Africa they are able to keep most medical personnel safe and save the lives of about half the patients. Of the patients treated in the U.S. however, only one has died and he was not properly treated in the early stages and perhaps not properly treated in the later stages either. But several people who received treatment elsewhere in the U.S. are alive and fully cured. And the prospects are good for the several people who are in treatment now. So let's see what can be done in an epidemic situation.
Step 5 - Mitigation. Ebola is a standard infectious disease. The virus is introduced into the body. It finds a cell and attacks it. It then seizes control of the cellular machinery and reprograms it so it starts making lots of copies of the virus. Eventually the cell can't take it any more. It explodes and the many copies of the virus escape and start searching out other cells to infect. This goes on for a while. Then the surveillance systems of the body figure out something is wrong. They start formulating a defense and attacking the viruses. Things soon start looking like two armies engaged in total war. Each side appropriates whatever resources it needs to take the fight to a new level. Eventually one side wins. If it is the virus the patient dies. If it is the defenses the patient lives. But like total war both armies wreck havoc. This havoc is what makes people sick. If the defenses kick into action early and are quickly successful the patient doesn't get very sick. If the defenses are slow or respond poorly then the havoc caused by the warring forces overwhelm the body and the patient dies. So the secret of success is twofold. First, keep the patient alive long enough for the defenses to overcome the virus. Second, do what you can to give the defenses what they need to be effective and to operate quickly.
Step 6 - Sharps. This isn't really a step. It's a problem. What if you have done everything well with your moon suit and it gets a hole poked in it? Now bad things can happen. In Africa, they are short on resources. So they put minimal effort into keeping patients alive. Their priority is keeping health workers safe. So they ban anything with a sharp edge. This means knives (scalpel anyone), needles (including IV needles), and even pretty much anything metal, like a bracket on a piece of furniture. If there is nothing around that can tear the moon suit it won't get torn. Remember in Africa they are very resource constrained. They have to stretch what they have as far as they can. Hopefully, even in an epidemic situation we will not be forced to take such drastic actions. So . . .
Step 7 - Basic support. If we can avoid the situation where the patient gets horribly sick then all kinds of good things happen. The body does not have to put up with nearly as much abuse while its defenses are dealing with the Ebola virus. This means more resources can be directed to the defense without putting the patient's life in danger. This also means the defense can work more quickly and effectively because it can use more resources without putting the body in danger. This improves the chances of the defense winning the race and the patient surviving. It also means a lot less contaminated material to deal with. Support can be very low tech. A lot of children in the third world die of dehydration. They get sick. They can't keep anything down. They get dehydrated. They die not of the sickness but dehydration. There is a simple and inexpensive solution that can literally be a lifesaver. It is a mixture of water and salt and sugar. The formula can be found on the internet and it is extremely cheap. The formula is designed to provide liquid to directly fight the dehydration and basic nutrition in the form of the sugar to keep the body strong. And the formula has been carefully designed to be easy on the digestive system. Kids that can't keep anything else down can often keep this solution down. So you feed the Ebola patient as long as they can keep anything down then switch to the solution. This keeps the patient in good shape further into the progression of the disease. This can make a great deal of difference.
Step 8 - Aggressive support. The standard hospital procedure for sick people is to start an IV and then push saline, nutrients, etc. The problem is that the end of the IV is a needle. This is a problem because of the whole "sharps" thing. But it is also a problem because of the fact that some Ebola patients in an advanced stage suffer a general deterioration of their blood vessels. This means it is hard to start an IV, keep the IV working, and avoid problems. Patients can bleed at the IV site because their blood vessels are in such bad shape. Apparently the top tier facilities can deal with this sort of thing at least some of the time. Certainly, if you can get the IV to work and you can avoid moon suit punctures then this should help the patient through the worst of the disease progression.
So let's review where we are at. We should be able to handle a large number of simultaneous patients as far as controlling the spread of infection. We can also keep the people caring for the patients safe. The only possible problem I see up to this level is whether there is a sufficient quantity of the materials to do Ebola tests. I think there probably is but I am not sure. Beyond that we can do some things for sure that improve the patient's chances of survival. This is not necessary to stop the epidemic but it is a good thing to do. I am not sure there are aggressive support measures that can be broadly deployed. If there are, so much the better. That leaves one more item:
Step 9 - Counterattack. So far I haven't covered anything having to do with going after the virus. There is one definitely feasible thing that can be done. As the body mounts a defense it creates antibodies. These assist the defense to get going more quickly and be more effective. Any patient that has had Ebola and survived has antibodies in their blood. In several cases matched blood from a survivor has been transfused into sick patients. It seems to help for pretty obvious and well understood reasons. This is a technique that is easy to ramp up. If you have lots of patients you should end up with a lesser number but still a substantial number of survivors. This should give you a pool that is large enough so that matching should be possible and the amount of blood should be significant. And as the epidemic ramps up the number of blood donors should also ramp up. Beyond that there are a number of booster drugs that have been developed. The problem is that none of them have been tested enough to determine if they help or not. And beyond that there are a number of vaccines that might prevent people from getting Ebola in the first place. Here too no one has been able to do enough testing to tell if they help or not.
So that's it. I have laid out how it is easily possible to deal with a widespread epidemic. So the unspoken great fear is not so fearsome. And let me finish with some more fear busting. Something like 50 people were on a tracking list due to their possible exposure to patient zero. This includes people who were cooped up in a small apartment with patient zero while he was very sick and therefore very contagious. Many of them have now cleared quarantine. They didn't catch Ebola. The rest of them will clear quarantine within a few days. So far none of them have caught the disease. In other words, what the experts have been saying all along is true. Ebola is fairly hard to catch. Of all the people who were exposed to patient zero only two nurses have caught the disease. And this group now includes lots of other medical professionals at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital who presumably also had lots of chances to catch the disease from patient zero.
I expect this news to filter out to the general public over the next few days. It will allay a lot of fears. It also looks likely that everyone in the U.S. who now has the disease will survive. This will also allay a lot of fears. Ebola goes from an "it kills everyone" disease to an "a lot of people survive it" disease. It would be nice if the news media super saturation coverage that has characterized the Ebola story to date would continue long enough to get this good news out. Instead I expect this news to disappear quickly. It just won't be able to compete with whatever we are supposed to be afraid of next.
There is a sophisticated and powerful entity at work in our culture. I am going to call it Fear, Inc. If you check with the Securities and Exchange Commission you will not find a company of that name listed. That's because it is an informal group acting in concert rather than an actual company. The name is an homage to Murder, Inc., another organization that was never incorporated. In the case of Murder, Inc. there was an actual group of specific people who identified with the name. It was the nickname used by a group of contract killers that worked for the mob in the '30s and '40s. Together they were purported to be responsible for between 100 and 500 murders. The group was ultimately broken up by a concerted effort by the federal government. Thomas E. Dewey was one of the government men who was part of the effort. He parlayed the notoriety he gained from busting up Murder, Inc. into a run for President as the candidate of the a Republican party.
With Murder Inc. were specific people you could point to. If you asked them and got an honest answer they would admit to being members of Murder, Inc. In some cases they would even see it as a source of pride. The membership in Fear, Inc. is much more widespread. And, like Murder, Inc. it is possible to identify members or the organization. But the members of Fear Inc. would vehemently deny being a member. In some cases they would go so far at to accuse others of being members. So while no one is willing to admit to being a part of Fear, Inc.there is definitely a fear industry. And while they might wish to decline the offer, I am willing to call people who do the work of the fear industry members of Fear, Inc. They deserve the accolade as much or more as the members of Murder, Inc. did. So who are these people? They are politicians and members of the news media. Let me start with an explanation of how this works when it comes to politicians.
At least theoretically in the old days politics was a "may the best man (it used to be all men) win" competition. On the other hand, Finley Peter Dunne in an 1895 newspaper column observed that "politics ain't beanbag". But for a long time afterward there still seemed to be an agreed on set of rules to the game. And one rule required everybody to at least pretended that political campaigns were about the great issues of the day and not trivia. That is manifestly no longer true today. In the past few days there has been a tornado of coverage concerning the fact that one candidate for the governorship of Florida likes to use a small fan to keep cool at political events. Coverage of the issues this contest should be about is conspicuous by its absence. And that's just one example of dozens I could point to. A lot of political coverage is about trivia and not about the great issues of the day. There is a new book out by Matt Bai called "All the Truth is Out: The Week Politics Went Tabloid". I have not read the book but I have heard good things about it. Bei contends that a substantial shift away from issues and toward trivia happened in a single specific week. I am not interested in the how or the when of this shift. I am only interested in the fact that it has happened.
With that as background consider two candidates: Smith and Jones. Both of them are vying for some political position. Both are human so both have flaws. Let's say you are Smith and Jones seems to be the better candidate when viewed through the lens of "the great issues of the day". What do you do? Most people do not put a lot of effort into picking a candidate to vote for. And if a candidate does a lot of "right" things but does one thing you think is very wrong what do you do? Well, in election after election in my experience, you vote for the other guy. You do this in spite of the fact that the other guy does a lot of wrong things. All that is necessary for things to work this way is for you to not have your nose rubbed in the wrong things the other guy does. This observation leads to the solution to Smith's problem.
Let's say you can pin something on your opponent. Let's say you can make that thing sound like a "terrible, horrible, no good, very bad" (to steal from a movie title) thing. And let's say your opponent fails to do the same thing back to you. Then you have the election in the bag. So is my analysis correct? It doesn't matter because political consultants believe it's true. So they advise candidates to "go negative", to find something that you can be pined on your opponent and make him or her sound "terrible, . . .". As just one example of this let me go all the way back to 1960 and the Kennedy/Nixon race for President. The conventional wisdom is that Kennedy won the TV version of the first debate because Nixon looked like he had a 5 o'clock shadow. The conventional wisdom also says that people listening to the same debate on the radio thought Nixon won it. That election was close and conventional wisdom says that the "5 o'clock shadow" debate tipped it to Kennedy. Once an idea like this gets established then people behave like it's true and whether it is actually true or not is longer important.
Now let's also say that voters think a particular election is not very important. They might think "there's not a dime's worth of difference between my two choices", for instance. What do voters who think like this do? Well, a lot of them stay home. It doesn't do a candidate any good to convince a voter she is the right candidate if that voter doesn't actually vote. But let's say that in a particular race one candidate is a bland nonentity but the other candidate is a "terrible, horrible, no good, very bad" candidate. Then voters who think like this will show up at the polls and vote reliably for the bland candidate. Why? Fear! They are afraid the "terrible, . . ." candidate will win and this, of course, will result in "terrible, . . ." things happening. If you want someone to actually do something specific then fear of a bad thing happening is a much more effective motivator than something where one of two things can happen and neither thing is very bad. This is true even if one of the things is much better than the other. Politicians, or more importantly their consultants, have figured this out. And this is why elections are so negative. Scaring voters into being afraid of your opponent is much more effective than convincing them of your wonderfulness.
And this is why political campaigns have become so horrible. Everyone hates them. Voters would much rather vote for some positive good thing than otherwise. Campaigns are designed to convince voters that one candidate is wonderful and the other candidate is horrible. But the efforts of each campaign to convince voters that the other guy is horrible are more effective than their campaign to convince voters that their guy is wonderful. This results an voters deciding both candidates are horrible, becoming disgusted with the whole business, and in many cases staying home. "A pox on both their houses." Nobody has figured out how to get out of this box. So all candidates are merchants of fear. They feel they have to do it to win elections. And if they can convince voters that the other candidate is to be feared and they are not to be feared then they are right. They will win the election.
A case can be made that some candidates or parties rely more heavily on fear than others. But everyone does it. And, of course, what works as an election strategy unfortunately is also applied to governance. Once a candidate is elected she wants to be seen as effective. Again there are tons of good things she can do. But voters don't remember. What they do remember is when you saved them from that "terrible, horrible, no good, very bad" thing happening. Again, it doesn't matter if it is actually "terrible, . . .". It only maters if you can sell the story that it is "terrible, . . .". So in the little time not devoted to fund raising for the next election, and there is almost always a next election, politicians search for and try to exploit whatever "terrible, . . ." thing comes their way. So that's why politicians carry water for Fear, Inc. Why does the news media?
Well, in a lot of ways the news media has the same problem politicians have. With politicians it's black and white. Either you win the election or you lose it. With the media it is shades of grey. But it ends up the same. You see the news media's job is not to tell you as clearly and as well as they can what's going on with an accent on the important stuff. The news media's job is to attract eyeballs so that their endeavors will result in high ad rates. The news media is in a continuous election situation. They win or lose not based on how many votes they get but on what their Neilson numbers are, or their subscription numbers are, or how many "click throughs" they get. And here too fear works. You have your choice of TV shows to watch or Internet channels to follow or newspapers to read. And in each case you also have the chance of "staying home" by not watching or following or reading the paper.
Again, harkening to a previous era, if you see a newspaper on a news stand and there is a three inch headline that says "WAR" are you going to buy the paper? Of course you are. Similarly, if you see a "WAR" banner on a web site you are certainly going to click through. War is a very frightening event. Now what happens if you see a much smaller headline saying "GDP up for fifth straight quarter" (definitely good news) or "talks stretch into third straight week" (neutral news), then what? You might decide to check in later or skip it altogether. And a decision like that, if repeated by many others, results in depressed ratings, clicks, or circulation. News organizations don't like that.
The history of CNN's rating bears this out. If there is a big story like a war their ratings go up. If it is a "slow news day" their ratings go down. And people are attracted to bad news more strongly than good. So it is in the economic interest of news organizations to convince the public that something bad has just happened or is about to happen. And, as with politicians, it doesn't much matter what the actual importance of the bad news is. It is only important that the public can be convinced that whatever it is, it's bad, very bad. The importance of finding "important" bad news has long since filtered down to front line reporters. They all know their job is to make "it", whatever "it" is, sound very bad. The reporters that don't "get the memo" either don't last long or they end up at news organizations no one has heard of.
Ebola falls squarely into this category. As I write this exactly one person has died in the U.S. and only a handful have contracted the disease. For comparison I checked out the "Around the Northwest" section of The Seattle Times, my local newspaper, for one day. I picked Saturday October 18 because nothing particular was going on. This feature is a collection of short items of interest (in the opinion of the editorial staff) to readers but which are not sufficiently important to rate a stand alone story. To give you an idea of what I'm talking about the feature takes up less than a whole page and appeared on page B-4 that day. However, this one selection from an unimportant part of the paper for one ordinary day gave details on three deaths. So the death of one person on one day across the entire United States should not be that big a deal. But vast amounts of coverage have been devoted to Ebola in the U.S. Currently there are a small number (less than ten) of other people in the U.S. who have been diagnosed with Ebola. But there is a good chance that all of them will live.
So the "Ebola in the U.S." story has been massively over-covered. And it has all been heavily laden with a "be afraid, be very afraid" subtext. In fact, in a lot of cases the "text" has been less than "sub". It has been blatant. And every wing and branch of the media has been guilty of fear mongering. Some outlets have been more guilty (Fox and other right wing outlets) but everybody has been doing it. One trick a lot of TV news uses is to have the talking head say the right things while video of ambulances and other scary stuff runs in the background. Another piece of conventional wisdom holds that pictures, particularly moving pictures (and the video they use always has a lot of movement in it) trump whatever the talking head is saying. So these other less-blatant outlets are just using a more subtle technique to scare us to death. And they can pull the trick off of getting the ratings while maintaining the fiction that they are responsible journalists. "Nice work, if you can get it, and you can get it if you try."
So politicians and the media are selling us fear. Why is it working? At some level everyone knows that one death and a handful of sick people are not that scary. Sure, there is great video of emergency vehicles running around with lots of lights flashing and people walking around in moon suits. I admit that's "compelling", as in "good for ratings" video. But it's not enough. So why did it work? In a word, epidemic.
If one person can die and a bunch of people can get sick what happens if a whole lot of people get sick? If we ignore the experts who claim it won't happen and assume it happens anyhow, what happens? "We're all going to die!", that's what happens. This is the fear mother load. "Responsible" journalists don't go there. Instead they drum up every tiny nugget of "some expert got it wrong" they can find and let people fill in the blanks. I am not going to rehash all the reasons why an epidemic is not going to happen. Instead I am just going to cut to the chase. I am going to assume that somehow an Ebola epidemic breaks out. We have thousands of people getting sick all over the place. What then?
Now that I have you on the edge of your seat I am going to make a digression. Early in my career I worked with a lot of IBM equipment and people. I got to know how IBM operated. The IBM of that period was a classic "not invented here" organization. To IBM's way of thinking if it wasn't invented or developed inside IBM it was no good. IBM was very successful for a long time with "not invented here". It was finally forced to change in the early '80s when it brought out the IBM PC, which was composed of parts (both hardware and software) that were, in fact, invented somewhere else. And those same Fear, Inc. yahoos, politicians and the media are now fierce proponents of "not invented here". Ebola was beneath notice as long as it was happening in Africa. Hundreds then thousands of deaths - not a problem. It's happening way over there. Ebola only became worthy of notice when it washed up on our shores.
That's bad. But what is worse is that our response to Ebola has suffered, and badly, from a serious case of "not invented here". Africa has been dealing with Ebola for decades. There have been dozens of outbreaks. They have all been contained. Is this current outbreak somehow different than the previous ones? Yes! But the differences are ones of scale rather than kind. This time Ebola broke out in countries that had non-existent medical systems. They also had poor to non-existent communications, roads, etc. So Ebola could break out and spread widely before anyone even knew anything was going on. When they did recognize they had a problem they lacked the resources to deal with it. Ebola is a problem in Africa not because no one knows what to do. It is a problem because no one has the resources to do what needs to be done. But that is all happening over there. So we flounder around trying to figure out what to do without making a serious effort to find out what they did over there that worked. A polite version of what we did instead goes by the phrase "reinventing the wheel". Why? Because judging by our actions we believe we are smart and special and everyone else is dumb and ordinary.
So let's say a large epidemic of Ebola broke out in the U.S. What should we do? Well, there's U.S. Ebola response, version 1. This is what Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital did. That resulted in patient zero dying and two health workers getting infected. So let's not do that. Then there's U.S. Ebola response version 2. The virtue of version 2 is that it's working. We have a small number of facilities that are set up to handle the most contagious diseases. So far no one treated at one of these facilities has died. And so far no one has caught Ebola at one of these facilities from the patients they are treating. These are both good things. The problem is that there are only four of these facilities and they can only handle about ten patients between them. If we have hundreds or thousands of infected people that's not going to work either. So we now move on to what I think a successful system for dealing with large numbers of Ebola patients would look like. Call it version 3.
And version 3 is based on what worked in Africa. Two countries in Africa have successfully eliminated Ebola after having had at least one case. If they can do it, we should be able to. Both of these countries are third world countries. What separates them from the countries where Ebola is endemic is that they both have primitive but functioning health care systems. All the countries where Ebola is raging are countries that recently emerged from civil war. Whatever health care system they had was wiped out by the war. The fact that there was no health care system to build on is what has made it so hard for these countries to get a handle on Ebola. But if you talk to the right people in Africa you can find out how to successfully defeat Ebola.
And it turns out that you don't really have to go to Africa. Doctors Without Borders is the U.S. branch of an international organization headquartered in France. Doctors Without Borders knows how to successfully deal with Ebola patients. Then there's the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation. An operation funded and organized by the Gates Foundation was the key to wiping Ebola out in Nigeria. So "who are you going to call?" Call the Gates Foundation or Doctors Without Borders. Pick whichever one you want or call both of them.
I have not actually called either of them. But if you poke around enough you can find out what they would say if you did call them. And here's the formula:
Step 1 - diagnosis. People who are not actively symptomatic are not dangerous. If a person is not running a temperature they are safe. So monitor people's temperature. There has been an argument about what the critical temperature is and people have said that the CDC screwed up by letting one of the current patients fly. She had a temperature but it was below the threshold. And at the time she had that temperature she probably was not dangerous. Her temperature later rose quite a bit and she came down with the disease. But so far none of the people on the plane with her have come down with the disease. (It is too soon to be 100% sure no one will come down but I'm betting none of them will.) The other thing to remember is there is a test for Ebola. The test doesn't take very long to get a result. But a person in early stages tests negative. Of course, at that point they are also not dangerous. I don't know if we have a lot of test kits. If we don't this could be a serious problem in an epidemic situation.
Step 2 - Isolation. We are currently using high end isolation units. That works but we only have a few. The "isolation" Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital used was ineffective. As is common, the media provides few in any details. But I suspect that the nurses that got infected had the wrong kind of protective gear or used it incorrectly. I do not fault them. As far as I can tell both of them followed directions. But what the Africa experience tells us is that all skin must be covered. The disease is transmitted by skin contact with infected bodily fluids (sweat, diarrhea, vomit, etc.). Some reports indicate their necks were exposed. The Africa experience also tells us that it is very difficult to properly disrobe. If infected bodily fluid on the outside of the protective gear ends up in contact with your skin you can get infected. The Africa experience recommends training and a buddy system. Your buddy verifies that you have donned and most importantly doffed your protective gear properly. My understanding is that the nurses were not using the buddy system. The gloves, moon suits, etc. are broadly available and can be procured in large numbers. The proper technique can be taught and adopting the buddy system is a matter of procedure. So all this can be easily scaled up to large numbers.
Step 3 - Disinfection part 1. It turns out that the virus is easy to kill. A chlorine solution works pretty well. So is a chlorine solution hard to come by? No! It's what you find in every swimming pool and hot tub. You can go to any Home and Garden store or Spa store and buy large bags of the proper chemical. And a single bag of the chemical goes a long way. You also need a sprayer. A bug sprayer from any Home and Garden story will do just fine. Part of the Isolation/Disinfection problem is where do you put all these sick people? Initially all the infected people of Texas Health Presbyterian were put in standard isolation rooms. That didn't work. So do we need to go all high tech like the units we are currently using? No! Tents in a field will work fine. That makes it easy to physically separate each patient and provide paths the care givers can use to go about their business while being physically separated from the source of the infection most of the time. We have lots of fields. And we have lots of tents. The Africa experience also recommends gravel. Why? Because they recommend a lot of sluicing people and things down with the chlorinated water. If the ground is gravel then everything drains away where no one can step on it.
Step 4 - disinfection part 2. People who get really sick with Ebola generate a large volume of bodily fluids. They can get a bad case of diarrhea. They can vomit a lot. They can sweat a lot. They can toss and turn a lot. So there is a lot of dangerous material generated. And this can get smeared around a lot. It can get on the clothes of the patient, the bed linen, the moon suit, anything else in the vicinity of the patient. You take all this together and there is a large volume of contaminated stuff to deal with. Texan health Presbyterian is rumored to have filled a room completely full of contaminated stuff. The Africa experience recommends burning all of it. This is harder to do than it would seem. You need to make sure no contaminated surface comes into contact with anything it's not supposed to. If you get all the contaminated material safely into the "burn box" of the incinerator (a high tech fire place) and you burn it all up then everything is fine.
One of our high tech isolation facilities uses a different solution. They autoclave everything. So what's an autoclave? It is a high tech pressure cooker that was invented about 150 years ago. It turns out there are some viruses (Ebola is not one of them) that can survive normal steam at 212 degrees Fahrenheit. An autoclave is a pressure container. You put some water and whatever you want to sterilize inside and fire it up. It heats the water under pressure. This lets the temperature rise to well over 212 thus killing everything. This idea of autoclaving everything works just fine. And there are a lot of autoclaves around if you look hard enough. But is there a third option that is less drastic than burning everything and easier to do than autoclaving everything? I think so. Get a back yard type inflatable swimming pool. Inflate it and fill it with chlorinated water. Then dump stuff in it like bed clothes, moon suits, whatever. Stir everything around thoroughly, say for 20 minutes. I think this would work fine. But if anybody has tested this I don't know about it. So this technique should only be tried if it turns out you can't burn everything or autoclave everything. But I bet it would work. It has the virtue of being a simple, cheap, high volume solution.
We are now done if all we want to do is stop the epidemic. Of course, a lot of our patients will die. So how about actually treating out patients and trying to save their lives? This is not necessary to stop the epidemic but it seems like a good idea if we can pull it off. Based on what we now know it may not be possible to save everyone. In the primitive conditions in Africa they are able to keep most medical personnel safe and save the lives of about half the patients. Of the patients treated in the U.S. however, only one has died and he was not properly treated in the early stages and perhaps not properly treated in the later stages either. But several people who received treatment elsewhere in the U.S. are alive and fully cured. And the prospects are good for the several people who are in treatment now. So let's see what can be done in an epidemic situation.
Step 5 - Mitigation. Ebola is a standard infectious disease. The virus is introduced into the body. It finds a cell and attacks it. It then seizes control of the cellular machinery and reprograms it so it starts making lots of copies of the virus. Eventually the cell can't take it any more. It explodes and the many copies of the virus escape and start searching out other cells to infect. This goes on for a while. Then the surveillance systems of the body figure out something is wrong. They start formulating a defense and attacking the viruses. Things soon start looking like two armies engaged in total war. Each side appropriates whatever resources it needs to take the fight to a new level. Eventually one side wins. If it is the virus the patient dies. If it is the defenses the patient lives. But like total war both armies wreck havoc. This havoc is what makes people sick. If the defenses kick into action early and are quickly successful the patient doesn't get very sick. If the defenses are slow or respond poorly then the havoc caused by the warring forces overwhelm the body and the patient dies. So the secret of success is twofold. First, keep the patient alive long enough for the defenses to overcome the virus. Second, do what you can to give the defenses what they need to be effective and to operate quickly.
Step 6 - Sharps. This isn't really a step. It's a problem. What if you have done everything well with your moon suit and it gets a hole poked in it? Now bad things can happen. In Africa, they are short on resources. So they put minimal effort into keeping patients alive. Their priority is keeping health workers safe. So they ban anything with a sharp edge. This means knives (scalpel anyone), needles (including IV needles), and even pretty much anything metal, like a bracket on a piece of furniture. If there is nothing around that can tear the moon suit it won't get torn. Remember in Africa they are very resource constrained. They have to stretch what they have as far as they can. Hopefully, even in an epidemic situation we will not be forced to take such drastic actions. So . . .
Step 7 - Basic support. If we can avoid the situation where the patient gets horribly sick then all kinds of good things happen. The body does not have to put up with nearly as much abuse while its defenses are dealing with the Ebola virus. This means more resources can be directed to the defense without putting the patient's life in danger. This also means the defense can work more quickly and effectively because it can use more resources without putting the body in danger. This improves the chances of the defense winning the race and the patient surviving. It also means a lot less contaminated material to deal with. Support can be very low tech. A lot of children in the third world die of dehydration. They get sick. They can't keep anything down. They get dehydrated. They die not of the sickness but dehydration. There is a simple and inexpensive solution that can literally be a lifesaver. It is a mixture of water and salt and sugar. The formula can be found on the internet and it is extremely cheap. The formula is designed to provide liquid to directly fight the dehydration and basic nutrition in the form of the sugar to keep the body strong. And the formula has been carefully designed to be easy on the digestive system. Kids that can't keep anything else down can often keep this solution down. So you feed the Ebola patient as long as they can keep anything down then switch to the solution. This keeps the patient in good shape further into the progression of the disease. This can make a great deal of difference.
Step 8 - Aggressive support. The standard hospital procedure for sick people is to start an IV and then push saline, nutrients, etc. The problem is that the end of the IV is a needle. This is a problem because of the whole "sharps" thing. But it is also a problem because of the fact that some Ebola patients in an advanced stage suffer a general deterioration of their blood vessels. This means it is hard to start an IV, keep the IV working, and avoid problems. Patients can bleed at the IV site because their blood vessels are in such bad shape. Apparently the top tier facilities can deal with this sort of thing at least some of the time. Certainly, if you can get the IV to work and you can avoid moon suit punctures then this should help the patient through the worst of the disease progression.
So let's review where we are at. We should be able to handle a large number of simultaneous patients as far as controlling the spread of infection. We can also keep the people caring for the patients safe. The only possible problem I see up to this level is whether there is a sufficient quantity of the materials to do Ebola tests. I think there probably is but I am not sure. Beyond that we can do some things for sure that improve the patient's chances of survival. This is not necessary to stop the epidemic but it is a good thing to do. I am not sure there are aggressive support measures that can be broadly deployed. If there are, so much the better. That leaves one more item:
Step 9 - Counterattack. So far I haven't covered anything having to do with going after the virus. There is one definitely feasible thing that can be done. As the body mounts a defense it creates antibodies. These assist the defense to get going more quickly and be more effective. Any patient that has had Ebola and survived has antibodies in their blood. In several cases matched blood from a survivor has been transfused into sick patients. It seems to help for pretty obvious and well understood reasons. This is a technique that is easy to ramp up. If you have lots of patients you should end up with a lesser number but still a substantial number of survivors. This should give you a pool that is large enough so that matching should be possible and the amount of blood should be significant. And as the epidemic ramps up the number of blood donors should also ramp up. Beyond that there are a number of booster drugs that have been developed. The problem is that none of them have been tested enough to determine if they help or not. And beyond that there are a number of vaccines that might prevent people from getting Ebola in the first place. Here too no one has been able to do enough testing to tell if they help or not.
So that's it. I have laid out how it is easily possible to deal with a widespread epidemic. So the unspoken great fear is not so fearsome. And let me finish with some more fear busting. Something like 50 people were on a tracking list due to their possible exposure to patient zero. This includes people who were cooped up in a small apartment with patient zero while he was very sick and therefore very contagious. Many of them have now cleared quarantine. They didn't catch Ebola. The rest of them will clear quarantine within a few days. So far none of them have caught the disease. In other words, what the experts have been saying all along is true. Ebola is fairly hard to catch. Of all the people who were exposed to patient zero only two nurses have caught the disease. And this group now includes lots of other medical professionals at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital who presumably also had lots of chances to catch the disease from patient zero.
I expect this news to filter out to the general public over the next few days. It will allay a lot of fears. It also looks likely that everyone in the U.S. who now has the disease will survive. This will also allay a lot of fears. Ebola goes from an "it kills everyone" disease to an "a lot of people survive it" disease. It would be nice if the news media super saturation coverage that has characterized the Ebola story to date would continue long enough to get this good news out. Instead I expect this news to disappear quickly. It just won't be able to compete with whatever we are supposed to be afraid of next.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)